The Ruling on Exiling a Woman, Her Performing Hajj, and the Obligation of a Mahram Traveling with Her
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
He says: Honorable Shaykh, may Allah grant you success, regarding the exiling of a woman, is it not sufficient to just imprison her? Because exiling her may lead to her corruption?
Answer:
If a mahram is available for her, then exiling her is obligatory. But if a mahram is not available for her, then there is no obligation of exiling her.
And is that Hajj obligatory for her? If a mahram is available for her, then Hajj is obligatory for her. If one is not available, then she waits until she finds a mahram. And is it obligatory for the mahram to go with her, even if it causes harm to his livelihood?
No, it is not obligatory for the mahram. But if he volunteers and wants to protect this woman, then it is recommended for him to do so, because he has no sin in doing so. It is not obligatory for him, because he has no sin even if he travels and drowns. Yes.
He says: Honorable Shaykh, may Allah grant you success, regarding the exiling of a woman, is it not sufficient to just imprison her? Because exiling her may lead to her corruption?
Answer:
If a mahram is available for her, then exiling her is obligatory. But if a mahram is not available for her, then there is no obligation of exiling her.
And is that Hajj obligatory for her? If a mahram is available for her, then Hajj is obligatory for her. If one is not available, then she waits until she finds a mahram. And is it obligatory for the mahram to go with her, even if it causes harm to his livelihood?
No, it is not obligatory for the mahram. But if he volunteers and wants to protect this woman, then it is recommended for him to do so, because he has no sin in doing so. It is not obligatory for him, because he has no sin even if he travels and drowns. Yes.
Source
سجن المرأة بدلا من التغريب — alfawzan.live
The Arabic text is a machine transcription of the audio recording.