The Ruling on Disciplining a Distinguishing Child by Imprisonment or Beating
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
Honorable Shaykh! If the pen is lifted as in the hadith, what is the ruling on what we call juvenile detention centers and imprisoning a minor if he commits a crime such as theft or others?
Answer:
Discipline: It is permissible to discipline a child. It is permissible to discipline a child if he is of the age of discernment so that he is raised properly and so that he acquires good morals. This falls under the category of discipline. Imprisoning him or giving him a light beating falls under the category of discipline. However, it is not permissible to beat him severely; he should be given a light beating, just as he is placed under a penalty. This is a matter of upbringing, and they are a matter of imprisonment; this is a matter of upbringing. If he is a habitual offender or has a mental defect, restraining him is to remove harm from people, or permanently, to treat him if he has a cure. Yes.
Honorable Shaykh! If the pen is lifted as in the hadith
From the child until he matures,
عن الصغير حتى يصبر،Answer:
Discipline: It is permissible to discipline a child. It is permissible to discipline a child if he is of the age of discernment so that he is raised properly and so that he acquires good morals. This falls under the category of discipline. Imprisoning him or giving him a light beating falls under the category of discipline. However, it is not permissible to beat him severely; he should be given a light beating, just as he is placed under a penalty. This is a matter of upbringing, and they are a matter of imprisonment; this is a matter of upbringing. If he is a habitual offender or has a mental defect, restraining him is to remove harm from people, or permanently, to treat him if he has a cure. Yes.
Source
تأديب الصغير المميز — alfawzan.live
The Arabic text is a machine transcription of the audio recording.