Al-Harās’s commentary on Ibn al-Qayyim’s statement in *Anwar al-‘Ibadah*
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
Chapter: What is your opinion of the statement of Muhammad al-Hirā’ in his commentary on the people of Ibn Ṭayyib: “Do not write *Anwar Āthār al-‘Ibadah* among the *Anwār* of al-Raḥmān,”
Answer:
Al-Harās (may Allah have mercy on him) made a supplementary note to the Shaykh and said that they are not [included] because they have now fallen into disbelief. The Sufis have now fallen into disbelief; they have not reached the *Anwār*. But this is a commentary that is not acceptable, because Ibn al-Qayyim is speaking about the principle, not about certain cases or certain individuals. Yes.
Chapter: What is your opinion of the statement of Muhammad al-Hirā’ in his commentary on the people of Ibn Ṭayyib: “Do not write *Anwar Āthār al-‘Ibadah* among the *Anwār* of al-Raḥmān,”
Answer:
Al-Harās (may Allah have mercy on him) made a supplementary note to the Shaykh and said that they are not [included] because they have now fallen into disbelief. The Sufis have now fallen into disbelief; they have not reached the *Anwār*. But this is a commentary that is not acceptable, because Ibn al-Qayyim is speaking about the principle, not about certain cases or certain individuals. Yes.
Source
شرح نونية ابن القيم [35] — alfawzan.live (53:31)
The Arabic text is a machine transcription of the audio recording.