Exiting the State of Ihram in Hajj and the Spread of Anomalous Opinions
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner:
In this year’s Hajj, last year’s, and the year before, there was confusion among people regarding those who did not leave Mina on the day of Eid until nightfall, with the claim that they return to the state of ihram as they were. What is your guidance, may Allah forgive you?
The Shaykh:
We should ask, may Allah make it clear and forgive him, Al-Albani, because he came across a hadith, a hadith stating that if one stays until night and does not complete the rites, he returns to the state of ihram. So he started spreading this among people and writing a fatwa based on it. And what I heard from His Eminence the Shaykh, may Allah have mercy on him, was that he said this is an anomalous hadith, a rejected hadith, and it is not acted upon. Yes.
The questioner:
And whoever exits the state of ihram on the day of Eid by doing one act, may Allah forgive you.
The Shaykh:
This is not permissible, this is not permissible. Exiting the state of ihram by doing one thing alone is not sufficient; it must be from two things: either stoning the pillars and shaving the head, or stoning the pillars and circumambulation. Yes. As for doing only one thing, this is not permissible. In all the books of Hajj rites that are in our hands, exiting the state of ihram does not occur except with two out of three, two out of three. None of them came with one. Yes.
The questioner:
Its broadcast.
The Shaykh:
Some people cause confusion. If they come across an opinion from some scholars or come across an anomalous hadith, they start calling for it, writing about it, and causing confusion among people.
The presenter:
May Allah reward you
In this year’s Hajj, last year’s, and the year before, there was confusion among people regarding those who did not leave Mina on the day of Eid until nightfall, with the claim that they return to the state of ihram as they were. What is your guidance, may Allah forgive you?
The Shaykh:
We should ask, may Allah make it clear and forgive him, Al-Albani, because he came across a hadith, a hadith stating that if one stays until night and does not complete the rites, he returns to the state of ihram. So he started spreading this among people and writing a fatwa based on it. And what I heard from His Eminence the Shaykh, may Allah have mercy on him, was that he said this is an anomalous hadith, a rejected hadith, and it is not acted upon. Yes.
The questioner:
And whoever exits the state of ihram on the day of Eid by doing one act, may Allah forgive you.
The Shaykh:
This is not permissible, this is not permissible. Exiting the state of ihram by doing one thing alone is not sufficient; it must be from two things: either stoning the pillars and shaving the head, or stoning the pillars and circumambulation. Yes. As for doing only one thing, this is not permissible. In all the books of Hajj rites that are in our hands, exiting the state of ihram does not occur except with two out of three, two out of three. None of them came with one. Yes.
The questioner:
Its broadcast.
The Shaykh:
Some people cause confusion. If they come across an opinion from some scholars or come across an anomalous hadith, they start calling for it, writing about it, and causing confusion among people.
The presenter:
May Allah reward you
Source
شرح نونية ابن القيم [48] — alfawzan.live (1:17:16)
The Arabic text is a machine transcription of the audio recording.