The Ruling on Deceiving People with an Anomalous Hadith Regarding Exiting the State of Ihram
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
May Allah reward you. This happened in Hajj this year, last year, and the year before: confusion was caused among people regarding those who did not throw the pebbles on the Day of 'Id until the evening, telling them that they return to the state of ihram as they were. What is your guidance? May Allah reward you.
Answer:
This is a matter that Al-Albani made prominent because he found a hadith, a hadith in which Ibn Hilal says, "He stayed the night and could not perform the rite properly, so he returns alone." So he went on to explain it to people and wrote a fatwa on it. And what I heard from Your Eminence, Shaykh Abdullah al-Aziz, was from the chapter saying, "This is an anomalous hadith, this is an anomalous hadith, it is not acted upon." Yes. And whoever exits the state of ihram on the Day of 'Id by doing one act, may Allah forgive you. This is not permissible, this is not permissible. Exiting the state of ihram by doing one thing is not permissible unless it involves two things: either the stoning and shaving, or the stoning and shortening the hair. Yes. As for doing only one act, this is not permissible. So in all the benefits that are in our hands, exiting the state of ihram does not occur except with two out of three, two out of three. No one has a following for one. Yes. If some people cause confusion, if they find a statement from some scholars or find an anomalous hadith, they go on to compose and strike at people and cause confusion among people.
May Allah reward you. This happened in Hajj this year, last year, and the year before: confusion was caused among people regarding those who did not throw the pebbles on the Day of 'Id until the evening, telling them that they return to the state of ihram as they were. What is your guidance? May Allah reward you.
Answer:
This is a matter that Al-Albani made prominent because he found a hadith, a hadith in which Ibn Hilal says, "He stayed the night and could not perform the rite properly, so he returns alone." So he went on to explain it to people and wrote a fatwa on it. And what I heard from Your Eminence, Shaykh Abdullah al-Aziz, was from the chapter saying, "This is an anomalous hadith, this is an anomalous hadith, it is not acted upon." Yes. And whoever exits the state of ihram on the Day of 'Id by doing one act, may Allah forgive you. This is not permissible, this is not permissible. Exiting the state of ihram by doing one thing is not permissible unless it involves two things: either the stoning and shaving, or the stoning and shortening the hair. Yes. As for doing only one act, this is not permissible. So in all the benefits that are in our hands, exiting the state of ihram does not occur except with two out of three, two out of three. No one has a following for one. Yes. If some people cause confusion, if they find a statement from some scholars or find an anomalous hadith, they go on to compose and strike at people and cause confusion among people.
Source
ترك طواف الإفاضة يوم النحر والتحلل فيه بفعل واحد — alfawzan.live
The Arabic text is a machine transcription of the audio recording.
