The Ruling on the Disobedient: Does He Exit Islam?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
He says: A necessary first thing in teaching Islam is belonging to the land. Does this mean that the Arabs exit Islam in this night in which any Islam passes?
Answer:
If you investigate the disobedient person, if his disobedience entails apostasy, then it is so. But if his disobedience does not entail apostasy, then he is not outside of Islam, but his Islam is weak, his Islam is weak, and he is a hypocrite. I prayed for one of the people of the Shari'ah. The Muslims are not on the same level; some have strong Islam and strong faith, and some do not, according to what issues from them of their deeds.
He says: A necessary first thing in teaching Islam is belonging to the land. Does this mean that the Arabs exit Islam in this night in which any Islam passes?
Answer:
If you investigate the disobedient person, if his disobedience entails apostasy, then it is so. But if his disobedience does not entail apostasy, then he is not outside of Islam, but his Islam is weak, his Islam is weak, and he is a hypocrite. I prayed for one of the people of the Shari'ah. The Muslims are not on the same level; some have strong Islam and strong faith, and some do not, according to what issues from them of their deeds.
Source
شرح الأصول الثلاثة [7] — alfawzan.live (1:03:27)
The Arabic text is a machine transcription of the audio recording.