Is it permissible for a pilgrim performing tamattu' to leave Makkah after his 'Umrah and then return to complete the Hajj?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
If a person intends to perform Hajj as a mutamatti' and arrives in the months of Hajj and performs 'Umrah, is it permissible for him to leave Makkah and then return on the eighth day to complete the Hajj?
Answer:
There is no harm if he has performed the 'Umrah. He can either stay in Makkah or return to his hometown if he wishes, provided he does not do anything that contradicts the ruling. However, the scholars differ on whether the obligation to sacrifice an animal for tamattu' is lifted if he travels a short distance between the 'Umrah and the Hajj, or if he remains a mutamatti'. It is correct that the obligation to sacrifice an animal for tamattu' is not lifted, even if he travels; he remains a mutamatti', and his state of tamattu' is not broken by travel, based on the general ruling. Yes.
If a person intends to perform Hajj as a mutamatti' and arrives in the months of Hajj and performs 'Umrah, is it permissible for him to leave Makkah and then return on the eighth day to complete the Hajj?
Answer:
There is no harm if he has performed the 'Umrah. He can either stay in Makkah or return to his hometown if he wishes, provided he does not do anything that contradicts the ruling. However, the scholars differ on whether the obligation to sacrifice an animal for tamattu' is lifted if he travels a short distance between the 'Umrah and the Hajj, or if he remains a mutamatti'. It is correct that the obligation to sacrifice an animal for tamattu' is not lifted, even if he travels; he remains a mutamatti', and his state of tamattu' is not broken by travel, based on the general ruling. Yes.
Source
قناة «العلامة الدكتور صالح الفوزان»، هل يجوز للحج المتمتع بعد عمرته أن يخرج من مكة ثم يعود لإكمال الحج؟ صالح الفوزان — youtube.com
The Arabic text is a machine transcription of the audio recording.