Stoning the Pillars Out of Order
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
I stoned the middle pillar, and then I learned about the large pillar, so I left it and stoned the pillar of 'Arafah. Then I went back and stoned the small pillar. Is this stoning valid? And if someone stoned the pillars out of order, and it was not intentional, is his stoning valid?
Answer:
The order is obligatory, indeed, the manner in which it was established. From it, then he returns to the middle one, then the pillar of 'Arafah. If he combines the manner at the end, that is the first option. So he repeats the middle one and repeats the pillar of 'Arafah so that it is after it. He repeats it now after the sun passes its zenith. He returns to the middle one, then the pillar of 'Arafah, so that it is after the first one.
I stoned the middle pillar, and then I learned about the large pillar, so I left it and stoned the pillar of 'Arafah. Then I went back and stoned the small pillar. Is this stoning valid? And if someone stoned the pillars out of order, and it was not intentional, is his stoning valid?
Answer:
The order is obligatory, indeed, the manner in which it was established. From it, then he returns to the middle one, then the pillar of 'Arafah. If he combines the manner at the end, that is the first option. So he repeats the middle one and repeats the pillar of 'Arafah so that it is after it. He repeats it now after the sun passes its zenith. He returns to the middle one, then the pillar of 'Arafah, so that it is after the first one.
Source
فتاوى الحج - ٣ — archive.org (20:01)
The Arabic text is a machine transcription of the audio recording.