Guidance for the one performing Tamattu' from among the people of Makkah
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
In his second question, he says: If one takes the 'Umrah from al-Half, and he is from the people of Makkah, in the months of Hajj, is the sacrificial animal (hady) obligatory upon him?
Answer:
It is not obligatory upon him, as long as he is from Makkah, it is not obligatory upon him, because Allah said that for the one who is not from the Sacred Mosque. So if he takes the 'Umrah from al-Tan'im or from the miqat, then the sacrificial animal (hady) is not obligatory upon him, the hady of tamattu'. He is performing tamattu', but he owes nothing, if he is a resident of Makkah. Yes.
In his second question, he says: If one takes the 'Umrah from al-Half, and he is from the people of Makkah, in the months of Hajj, is the sacrificial animal (hady) obligatory upon him?
Answer:
It is not obligatory upon him, as long as he is from Makkah, it is not obligatory upon him, because Allah said that for the one who is not from the Sacred Mosque. So if he takes the 'Umrah from al-Tan'im or from the miqat, then the sacrificial animal (hady) is not obligatory upon him, the hady of tamattu'. He is performing tamattu', but he owes nothing, if he is a resident of Makkah. Yes.
Source
فتاوى الحج 1410 هـ - 17 — archive.org (3:20)
The Arabic text is a machine transcription of the audio recording.