The Error in the Order of Stoning the Pillars
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
A man threw the small pillar on the morning of the festival by mistake. On one of the days of the festival, he threw the large pillar, then went back and threw the small one, then the middle one, then the large one. What is the ruling in this case?
Answer:
The one who threw the festival pillar without guidance, throwing it from the side of the wall, should repeat the throwing this evening or early tomorrow after the sun passes its zenith. He should repeat it after the sun passes its zenith, starting with the festival pillar. He should start with it from the southern side so that he throws it into the basin. Then he should repeat the pillar of that day. He should repeat it. Then he should throw the pillar for tomorrow, and so on. As for the one who reversed the order, starting with the large pillar from the side of Makkah, he should repeat the middle and the last pillar. He should repeat them this evening first, after the sun passes its zenith, throwing the middle one and then the last one, so that his throwing of them is in descending order toward Makkah. Then he should repeat it and throw the pillar for tomorrow, if Allah wills. Yes.
A man threw the small pillar on the morning of the festival by mistake. On one of the days of the festival, he threw the large pillar, then went back and threw the small one, then the middle one, then the large one. What is the ruling in this case?
Answer:
The one who threw the festival pillar without guidance, throwing it from the side of the wall, should repeat the throwing this evening or early tomorrow after the sun passes its zenith. He should repeat it after the sun passes its zenith, starting with the festival pillar. He should start with it from the southern side so that he throws it into the basin. Then he should repeat the pillar of that day. He should repeat it. Then he should throw the pillar for tomorrow, and so on. As for the one who reversed the order, starting with the large pillar from the side of Makkah, he should repeat the middle and the last pillar. He should repeat them this evening first, after the sun passes its zenith, throwing the middle one and then the last one, so that his throwing of them is in descending order toward Makkah. Then he should repeat it and throw the pillar for tomorrow, if Allah wills. Yes.
Source
فتاوى الحج - ١ - ١٤٠٥ هـ — archive.org (27:03)
The Arabic text is a machine transcription of the audio recording.
