The Dispute Between Pilgrims and Its Effect on the Validity of Hajj
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
The question says: A woman performed Hajj, and it was her obligatory Hajj. A dispute arose between her and a pilgrim who was performing Hajj on behalf of his deceased grandfather. Does this count as arguing during Hajj? It was said to her that because of this dispute, your Hajj will not be completed. He asked: Is that necessarily the case? What is the ruling on this?
Answer:
If the calling out did not involve cursing, insulting, or harming, it is not permissible. However, if the calling out involved cursing, insulting, false speech, and lying, then they must repent, and their Hajj is valid. They must repent and feel remorse for what happened between them, and their Hajj is valid in any case. But if it was accompanied by arguing for falsehood or sins, there is a deficiency in the Hajj, a deficiency in the reward. If they repent and make amends, Allah the Exalted and Majestic is He who accepts the repentance of those who repent, and their Hajj is valid for both of them. Yes.
The presenter:
May you love Allah.
The question says: A woman performed Hajj, and it was her obligatory Hajj. A dispute arose between her and a pilgrim who was performing Hajj on behalf of his deceased grandfather. Does this count as arguing during Hajj? It was said to her that because of this dispute, your Hajj will not be completed. He asked: Is that necessarily the case? What is the ruling on this?
Answer:
If the calling out did not involve cursing, insulting, or harming, it is not permissible. However, if the calling out involved cursing, insulting, false speech, and lying, then they must repent, and their Hajj is valid. They must repent and feel remorse for what happened between them, and their Hajj is valid in any case. But if it was accompanied by arguing for falsehood or sins, there is a deficiency in the Hajj, a deficiency in the reward. If they repent and make amends, Allah the Exalted and Majestic is He who accepts the repentance of those who repent, and their Hajj is valid for both of them. Yes.
The presenter:
May you love Allah.
Source
فتاوى الحج ١٤١٠ هـ - ٨ — archive.org (57:59)
The Arabic text is a machine transcription of the audio recording.
