The Sa'y of the Arrival Tawaf in Place of the Sa’y of the Ifadah Tawaf
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
This questioner asks: Does the sa’y performed with the arrival tawaf suffice in place of the sa’y for the ifadah tawaf for the one performing tamattu’ and the one performing ifrad?
Answer:
For the one performing tamattu’, the sa’y is sufficient; he must perform a second sa’y for his Hajj, having exited the state of ihram from his ‘Umrah. If he performed the tawaf, shortened his hair, and exited the state of ihram, he must perform a second sa’y for his ‘Umrah. As for the one who came directly and the one performing ifrad, if they performed the sa’y with the arrival tawaf and did not exit the state of ihram, the first sa’y suffices for them, and the tawaf for ifadah is after the Hajj.
The presenter:
May Allah reward you with good.
This questioner asks: Does the sa’y performed with the arrival tawaf suffice in place of the sa’y for the ifadah tawaf for the one performing tamattu’ and the one performing ifrad?
Answer:
For the one performing tamattu’, the sa’y is sufficient; he must perform a second sa’y for his Hajj, having exited the state of ihram from his ‘Umrah. If he performed the tawaf, shortened his hair, and exited the state of ihram, he must perform a second sa’y for his ‘Umrah. As for the one who came directly and the one performing ifrad, if they performed the sa’y with the arrival tawaf and did not exit the state of ihram, the first sa’y suffices for them, and the tawaf for ifadah is after the Hajj.
The presenter:
May Allah reward you with good.
Source
فتاوى الحج ١٤١٠ هـ - ١ — archive.org (18:40)
The Arabic text is a machine transcription of the audio recording.