Staying overnight in Makkah for one who hastens after the stoning
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
A man wants to hasten, so he stoned the pillars in the afternoon of the twelfth day, then he went out to Makkah and spent the night of the thirteenth there. Is it obligatory for him to stay overnight, and for the man?
Answer:
If he is in Makkah, no. If he spent the night in Makkah, no. The one who is required to stay overnight is the one in Mina. As for the one who stays overnight in Makkah, or in Muzdalifah, or in al-'Aziziyah, it is not required of him. If he left before sunset on that day, he is not required to stay overnight, and there is no penalty. He is only required to stay overnight in Mina. As for if he left Mina for al-'Aziziyah or to Makkah and stayed there, nothing remains upon him. He performs the farewell tawaf and leaves. Yes.
The presenter:
May Allah reward you,
A man wants to hasten, so he stoned the pillars in the afternoon of the twelfth day, then he went out to Makkah and spent the night of the thirteenth there. Is it obligatory for him to stay overnight, and for the man?
Answer:
If he is in Makkah, no. If he spent the night in Makkah, no. The one who is required to stay overnight is the one in Mina. As for the one who stays overnight in Makkah, or in Muzdalifah, or in al-'Aziziyah, it is not required of him. If he left before sunset on that day, he is not required to stay overnight, and there is no penalty. He is only required to stay overnight in Mina. As for if he left Mina for al-'Aziziyah or to Makkah and stayed there, nothing remains upon him. He performs the farewell tawaf and leaves. Yes.
The presenter:
May Allah reward you,
Source
فتاوى الحج 1410 هـ - 12 — archive.org (57:59)
The Arabic text is a machine transcription of the audio recording.