The Guidance for One Who Enters Ihram for 'Umrah from Yemen and Then Visits al-Madinah
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
This questioner says: We came from Yemen and entered ihram for 'Umrah from Yalamlam. Then we went to al-Madinah to visit, and after that we entered ihram for Hajj individually. Do we have to offer a sacrificial animal? Because we asked one of the scholars at the mosque, and he said there is nothing required of you?
Answer:
The hady, or not? Because you are in the state of tamattu', and even if you go to al-Madinah, if you slaughter, that is what is appropriate, because slaughtering in al-Madinah does not prevent your tamattu'. Some scholars hold that you slaughter in al-Madinah, because travel exempts you from the blood (sacrifice), but if you slaughter, it is more preferable and more cautious. The apparent indication of the Shari'ah evidence is that you are in the state of tamattu', and even if you go to al-Madinah, you slaughter the sacrificial animal here or in Makkah. He called it hady, he called it fidyah. Yes.
This questioner says: We came from Yemen and entered ihram for 'Umrah from Yalamlam. Then we went to al-Madinah to visit, and after that we entered ihram for Hajj individually. Do we have to offer a sacrificial animal? Because we asked one of the scholars at the mosque, and he said there is nothing required of you?
Answer:
The hady, or not? Because you are in the state of tamattu', and even if you go to al-Madinah, if you slaughter, that is what is appropriate, because slaughtering in al-Madinah does not prevent your tamattu'. Some scholars hold that you slaughter in al-Madinah, because travel exempts you from the blood (sacrifice), but if you slaughter, it is more preferable and more cautious. The apparent indication of the Shari'ah evidence is that you are in the state of tamattu', and even if you go to al-Madinah, you slaughter the sacrificial animal here or in Makkah. He called it hady, he called it fidyah. Yes.
Source
فتاوى الحج 1410 هـ - 9 — archive.org (3:10)
The Arabic text is a machine transcription of the audio recording.