Is silence regarding the vocalization of the reciter's words considered approval?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner:
He says: Honorable Shaykh, may Allah grant you success, does your silence regarding the vocalization of the brother reciter's reading constitute approval of it and correction of his recitation?
The Shaykh:
In what respect?
The questioner:
Vocalizing the words is considered approval of it and correction of his recitation; because we love to combine the two good things: jurisprudence and language. He read just now "la thaman malk," like this. Is this the pronunciation, or is it with a dammah?
The Shaykh:
I do not know what the phrase you read was. This is up to you, it is not up to me. Yes.
The questioner:
And he says: "la min ra's mal wa thaman malk."
The Shaykh:
And what did you read it as?
The questioner:
With a kasrah on the mīm: "malk."
The Shaykh:
It is not permissible. "Malk" is permissible. "Malk" and "malk" do not contradict each other. Correct your understanding, you who are asking. Yes.
He says: Honorable Shaykh, may Allah grant you success, does your silence regarding the vocalization of the brother reciter's reading constitute approval of it and correction of his recitation?
The Shaykh:
In what respect?
The questioner:
Vocalizing the words is considered approval of it and correction of his recitation; because we love to combine the two good things: jurisprudence and language. He read just now "la thaman malk," like this. Is this the pronunciation, or is it with a dammah?
The Shaykh:
I do not know what the phrase you read was. This is up to you, it is not up to me. Yes.
The questioner:
And he says: "la min ra's mal wa thaman malk."
The Shaykh:
And what did you read it as?
The questioner:
With a kasrah on the mīm: "malk."
The Shaykh:
It is not permissible. "Malk" is permissible. "Malk" and "malk" do not contradict each other. Correct your understanding, you who are asking. Yes.
Source
الفوزان -أشرطة- شرح زاد المستقنع مع الأسئلة - 087-نفقة الأقارب والمماليك - 17-7-25 هـ — archive.org (55:24)
The Arabic text is a machine transcription of the audio recording.
