The Ruling on Not Mentioning the Chain of Narration When Transmitting Hadiths
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
The hadith of Buraydah: the author did not mention its chain of narration to the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him). What is your view on that?
Answer:
It is sufficient that it is in the Sahih. The author does not mention the chains of narration, just as many other scholars do; they transmit hadiths by mentioning only the Companion narrator, the narrator from among the Companions. As for the chain of narration, it is found in the collections of the Sunnah, because transmitting it would lengthen and bloat the book. It is available in the collections of the Sunnah, and one can refer to it there. This is a matter of brevity, a matter of brevity. Yes. The question, Shaykh, I think he intends.
And in al-Maram, there is only al-Muntaqa, and in Riad al-Saliheen, many books mention only the Companion and do not transmit the chains of narration, because transmitting them bloats the book and lengthens it for the reader and the listener, even though transmitting them does not bring great benefit, because they are found in their proper places. Whoever wants to look into the chain of narration can refer to the book from which it was transmitted. And this hadith is transmitted from Sahih Muslim. Yes.
The hadith of Buraydah: the author did not mention its chain of narration to the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him). What is your view on that?
Answer:
It is sufficient that it is in the Sahih. The author does not mention the chains of narration, just as many other scholars do; they transmit hadiths by mentioning only the Companion narrator, the narrator from among the Companions. As for the chain of narration, it is found in the collections of the Sunnah, because transmitting it would lengthen and bloat the book. It is available in the collections of the Sunnah, and one can refer to it there. This is a matter of brevity, a matter of brevity. Yes. The question, Shaykh, I think he intends.
And in al-Maram, there is only al-Muntaqa, and in Riad al-Saliheen, many books mention only the Companion and do not transmit the chains of narration, because transmitting them bloats the book and lengthens it for the reader and the listener, even though transmitting them does not bring great benefit, because they are found in their proper places. Whoever wants to look into the chain of narration can refer to the book from which it was transmitted. And this hadith is transmitted from Sahih Muslim. Yes.
Source
الفوزان -أشرطة- أسئلة وأجوبة من دروس التوحيد - الفوزان - أسئلة التوحيد - ٣ — archive.org (48:19)
The Arabic text is a machine transcription of the audio recording.