The ruling on a man buying an item at whatever price the market settles on, if the item is sold at the last price he bought it for?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
He says: Honorable Shaykh, may Allah grant you success, among the Bedouin people, certain forms of sale are common, and we do not know whether they are valid or not. For example, a man wants to buy a sheep, for instance, or a camel, and he says to the seller, "I will buy this item from you at whatever price the market settles on." If the item is sold at the last price he bought it from him, he might even say to him, "I will add to whatever the price settles on." What is the ruling on that? That is, he took the animal and said to him, "I will pay you based on what the price of sheep or camels ends up being."
Answer:
This is what passed before us: selling at whatever price the market settles on is not permissible because it is unknown. One does not know at what price the market will settle, so this is unknown. Some scholars have allowed this, saying that people’s need calls for it and the excessive uncertainty in it is slight. But the school of thought is that it is not permissible, and that is the closer view in order to ward off harm from people.
He says: Honorable Shaykh, may Allah grant you success, among the Bedouin people, certain forms of sale are common, and we do not know whether they are valid or not. For example, a man wants to buy a sheep, for instance, or a camel, and he says to the seller, "I will buy this item from you at whatever price the market settles on." If the item is sold at the last price he bought it from him, he might even say to him, "I will add to whatever the price settles on." What is the ruling on that? That is, he took the animal and said to him, "I will pay you based on what the price of sheep or camels ends up being."
Answer:
This is what passed before us: selling at whatever price the market settles on is not permissible because it is unknown. One does not know at what price the market will settle, so this is unknown. Some scholars have allowed this, saying that people’s need calls for it and the excessive uncertainty in it is slight. But the school of thought is that it is not permissible, and that is the closer view in order to ward off harm from people.
Source
قناة «العلامة الدكتور صالح الفوزان»، [1153 -2802] حكم شراء الرجل السلعة بما يقف السعر عليه، فإذا وقف المبيع على آخر سعر اشتراه؟ — youtube.com
