The response of the lesser truthful one to advice on the grounds that the advisor is not his guardian
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
This questioner says: I have a friend who is younger than me in age and knowledge, and I always guide him, enjoin good upon him, and forbid evil from him. Does he have the right to disobey me on the grounds that I am not his wali al-amr (one in authority)?
Answer:
No, you have fulfilled your obligation, and it is obligatory upon him to accept the truth. He should not say, "You are not my wali al-amr." You are his brother advising him. It is obligatory upon me to forbid evil from you and enjoin good upon you. This is your right over me, and it is obligatory upon me.
This questioner says: I have a friend who is younger than me in age and knowledge, and I always guide him, enjoin good upon him, and forbid evil from him. Does he have the right to disobey me on the grounds that I am not his wali al-amr (one in authority)?
Answer:
No, you have fulfilled your obligation, and it is obligatory upon him to accept the truth. He should not say, "You are not my wali al-amr." You are his brother advising him. It is obligatory upon me to forbid evil from you and enjoin good upon you. This is your right over me, and it is obligatory upon me.
Source
وجوب الأمر بالمعروف والنهي عن المنكر، المقدمة — islamhouse.com (45:20)
The Arabic text is a machine transcription of the audio recording.