The Difference Between the Obligatory Hady and the Hady of Tamattu' in the Place of Slaughter
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner:
There is a difference between the obligatory hady and the hady of tamattu' regarding slaughter in Makkah.
The Shaykh:
The hadith is general in its wording, and its command is broad. For this reason, the Companions used to eat and marry in Madinah.
The questioner:
But the slaughter is all in Makkah.
The Shaykh:
The blood is in Makkah, but there is no issue with the meat. The hady is in Mina or Makkah; it is hady, but he provisions himself. As for the sacrifices, their matter is broad. As for what is for abandoning an obligation or committing a forbidden act, this does not leave Makkah. It must be distributed to the poor of Makkah. By His saying, Glorified and Exalted is He... I should have combined the hadiths with each other. I say, the hadiths should be combined with each other. Yes. The hadith of Ali is authentic that it is permissible to slaughter the horn bone. It is authentic. Yes.
There is a difference between the obligatory hady and the hady of tamattu' regarding slaughter in Makkah.
The Shaykh:
The hadith is general in its wording, and its command is broad. For this reason, the Companions used to eat and marry in Madinah.
The questioner:
But the slaughter is all in Makkah.
The Shaykh:
The blood is in Makkah, but there is no issue with the meat. The hady is in Mina or Makkah; it is hady, but he provisions himself. As for the sacrifices, their matter is broad. As for what is for abandoning an obligation or committing a forbidden act, this does not leave Makkah. It must be distributed to the poor of Makkah. By His saying, Glorified and Exalted is He... I should have combined the hadiths with each other. I say, the hadiths should be combined with each other. Yes. The hadith of Ali is authentic that it is permissible to slaughter the horn bone. It is authentic. Yes.
Source
شرح كتاب المنتقى من أخبار المصطفى صلى الله عليه وسلم [ الشرح الأول ]، بداية من باب تحلل المحصر عن العمرة بالنحر ثم الحلق حيث أحصر من حل أو حرم — islamhouse.com (1:09:29)
The Arabic text is a machine transcription of the audio recording.