Giving a sister a gift after returning the money she had lent him
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
A man says: My sister gave me a sum of money on the condition that I buy a car with it and sell it on installment. Then I needed the aforementioned sum, so I took it and calculated a car as a debt on myself without actually buying a car. Then I asked some students of knowledge, and they told me that this is not permissible. So, is it permissible for me to give my sister a gift from my money after returning her money to her, to be compensation for having detained her money with me, or not?
Answer:
If you give her something, there is no harm. If they drink it, it is conditional. The best of people are those who are good in judgment. Since you deprived her of the benefit, if you return her money and give her something and say, "Forgive me," that is good. The best of people are those who are good in judgment. Yes.
A man says: My sister gave me a sum of money on the condition that I buy a car with it and sell it on installment. Then I needed the aforementioned sum, so I took it and calculated a car as a debt on myself without actually buying a car. Then I asked some students of knowledge, and they told me that this is not permissible. So, is it permissible for me to give my sister a gift from my money after returning her money to her, to be compensation for having detained her money with me, or not?
Answer:
If you give her something, there is no harm. If they drink it, it is conditional. The best of people are those who are good in judgment. Since you deprived her of the benefit, if you return her money and give her something and say, "Forgive me," that is good. The best of people are those who are good in judgment. Yes.
Source
التعليق على كتاب زاد المعاد، بداية من فصل : فى أمر رسول الله - صلى الله عليه وسلم - الثلاثة باعتزال نساءهم — islamhouse.com (42:51)
The Arabic text is a machine transcription of the audio recording.