The ruling on taking something from another person if the owner permits it
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
Some people take something from a person and then say, “I want this thing to be a gift.” Is it discarded?
Answer:
If he permits it, he takes it; if he permits it, he asks for permission; or if he permits it, tell him he is wrong, and return to him what was taken from him. If he permits it with a genuine willingness, out of fear of his evil, or for other reasons, there is no harm. If he permits it with a willingness that is known to be out of contentment, not out of coercion, and not out of fear, there is no harm.
Some people take something from a person and then say, “I want this thing to be a gift.” Is it discarded?
Answer:
If he permits it, he takes it; if he permits it, he asks for permission; or if he permits it, tell him he is wrong, and return to him what was taken from him. If he permits it with a genuine willingness, out of fear of his evil, or for other reasons, there is no harm. If he permits it with a willingness that is known to be out of contentment, not out of coercion, and not out of fear, there is no harm.
Source
شرح بلوغ المرام [ ابن باز ] [ الشرح الجديد ]، تابع باب الهبة — islamhouse.com (11:37)
The Arabic text is a machine transcription of the audio recording.