The Argument from the Hadith: “And He made its soil for us a means of purification” Regarding Tayammum with Soil

Question:
Honorable Shaykh, may Allah grant you success. In the hadith of Hudhayfah (may Allah be pleased with him) in Sahih , those who say that tayammum is not valid except with soil use it as evidence, contrary to those who say that the term "sa'id" (earth) is general and unrestricted. His question is: Is his argument with this sound?

Answer:
Yes. Those who said that tayammum is valid on the entire pure surface of the earth hold that it must be pure; if it is impure, one does not perform tayammum with it, but if it is pure, they took the general meaning. . The generality of this. And the narration "its soil is a means of purification." This was taken by those who specified that tayammum is with soil. Similarly, Allah the Exalted said: "Take pure earth." Sa'id is the dust that rises. "Wipe your faces and your hands with it." "With it" and "min" (from) indicate partiality, so they said that something from the earth must stick to his hand with which he wipes his face and his palms. The first group took the general meaning and said, "And He made its soil," this is one of the instances of the general, one of the instances of the general. And the general is not specified if this is from it; if it means the general, it is only specified by something other than its instances. As for its instances, they are included in it. So his saying includes soil and includes other than soil from the surface of the earth.