Rulings on the Sa'i, Prayer in It, and Tawaf with It
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner:
And something. And something of assistance, because the Shaykh
The Shaykh:
I said it is not part of the Sacred Mosque. I say it is not part of the Sacred Mosque, whereas it is an independent station, yes.
The questioner:
On the slides. So it is another publication from.
The Shaykh:
Prayer in it is permissible; it is permissible just like in the Sacred Mosque. It is permissible for those in the Sa'i to pray in their place due to the narrowness. If they are permitted to pray in the streets, how would it not be permissible for them to pray in the Sa'i? This is permissible and there is no problem with it. But the discussion is if we say it is part of the Sacred Mosque, then you do not enter the wall and you do not sit in it, even though the correct view is that you enter the wall in the Sa'i and sit in it and perform Sa'i between al-Safa and al-Marwah, so it does not take on the rulings of the Sacred Mosque from this aspect. As for the multiplication of reward, everything that is within the miles, everything that is within the boundaries of the Haram, is included in the multiplication, because it is all called the Sacred Mosque from the aspect of multiplication, yes, not from the aspect of the specific rulings. So the Sa'i has the rulings of the Sacred Mosque; it has rulings because it is an independent station. This was made for the Sa'i and this was made for the Tawaf around the Ka'bah. So if one performs Tawaf with the Sa'i, notice this: if one performs Tawaf with the Sa'i, his Tawaf is not valid, because he did not perform Tawaf around the place of Tawaf; he performed Tawaf outside the mosque, because the Sa'i is considered outside the mosque. And this is a matter that requires attention, because it has reached us that some of the people performing Tawaf, when the mosque becomes crowded, go out with the Sa'i. Does this or not make their Tawaf valid?
And something. And something of assistance, because the Shaykh
The Shaykh:
I said it is not part of the Sacred Mosque. I say it is not part of the Sacred Mosque, whereas it is an independent station, yes.
The questioner:
On the slides. So it is another publication from.
The Shaykh:
Prayer in it is permissible; it is permissible just like in the Sacred Mosque. It is permissible for those in the Sa'i to pray in their place due to the narrowness. If they are permitted to pray in the streets, how would it not be permissible for them to pray in the Sa'i? This is permissible and there is no problem with it. But the discussion is if we say it is part of the Sacred Mosque, then you do not enter the wall and you do not sit in it, even though the correct view is that you enter the wall in the Sa'i and sit in it and perform Sa'i between al-Safa and al-Marwah, so it does not take on the rulings of the Sacred Mosque from this aspect. As for the multiplication of reward, everything that is within the miles, everything that is within the boundaries of the Haram, is included in the multiplication, because it is all called the Sacred Mosque from the aspect of multiplication, yes, not from the aspect of the specific rulings. So the Sa'i has the rulings of the Sacred Mosque; it has rulings because it is an independent station. This was made for the Sa'i and this was made for the Tawaf around the Ka'bah. So if one performs Tawaf with the Sa'i, notice this: if one performs Tawaf with the Sa'i, his Tawaf is not valid, because he did not perform Tawaf around the place of Tawaf; he performed Tawaf outside the mosque, because the Sa'i is considered outside the mosque. And this is a matter that requires attention, because it has reached us that some of the people performing Tawaf, when the mosque becomes crowded, go out with the Sa'i. Does this or not make their Tawaf valid?
Source
شرح بلوغ المرام من أدلة الأحكام [ صالح الفوزان ]، تابع باب الغسل وحكم الجنب — islamhouse.com (1:00:50)
The Arabic text is a machine transcription of the audio recording.