The Ruling on the Udhiyah for the Pilgrim
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
Is it recommended for the pilgrim to offer the udhiyah?
Answer:
The udhiyah is general. It is a recommended practice (sunnah) for pilgrims and others. For men, women, and people of the desert, the sunnah is general. The udhiyah is general for everyone. People of the desert offer the udhiyah, and people of cities and villages offer the udhiyah, and people of Makkah offer the udhiyah, and pilgrims do so as well. It was reported in the surah that he offered a sacrifice on the day of Hajj with two cows that were brought to him. So the point is that the udhiyah is general. If he offers a sacrifice in Makkah, other than the hady which is the hady of tamattu', but he has the hady of tamattu', the udhiyah is one thing, and the hady of tamattu' is another. Yes.
Is it recommended for the pilgrim to offer the udhiyah?
Answer:
The udhiyah is general. It is a recommended practice (sunnah) for pilgrims and others. For men, women, and people of the desert, the sunnah is general. The udhiyah is general for everyone. People of the desert offer the udhiyah, and people of cities and villages offer the udhiyah, and people of Makkah offer the udhiyah, and pilgrims do so as well. It was reported in the surah that he offered a sacrifice on the day of Hajj with two cows that were brought to him. So the point is that the udhiyah is general. If he offers a sacrifice in Makkah, other than the hady which is the hady of tamattu', but he has the hady of tamattu', the udhiyah is one thing, and the hady of tamattu' is another. Yes.
Source
وجوب أداء الأمانة ورعايتها — islamhouse.com (57:05)
The Arabic text is a machine transcription of the audio recording.