Is a girl sinful if she does not go out to visit her relatives and maintain family ties if her father dislikes her leaving the house and she fears him?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
Is it obligatory for a girl who lives under the care of her parents, who has reached the age of maturity, or is over twenty-four years old, to visit the sick, such as a neighbor or one of the family members? And is it obligatory for her to maintain family ties? Knowing that her father dislikes her leaving the house out of fear for her from harms, and knowing that her leaving would be with her mother’s permission, and her father is absent from the house, does she sin if she does not perform those visits out of fear of her father’s anger? We ask for your information and guidance, may Allah reward you with good.
Answer:
Visiting relatives, neighbors, and Muslim brothers is undoubtedly a good thing and is encouraged. However, regarding a young woman who is feared to fall into fitnah (trial, discord or temptation) and it is not her custom to go out in public, she does not leave the house. This is called khufrah (seclusion); she is called non-public because fitnah is feared from her. Because her visiting her relatives or her neighbors is a recommended practice (mustahabb), whereas her going out with fitnah is forbidden (haram). So she does not commit a forbidden act in order to perform a recommended practice; because the harm here outweighs the benefit.
The result is that in this matter, benefits, harms, and utilities are considered. So if her going out does not lead to fitnah, then she goes out and visits her relatives and visits her neighbors. But if her going out leads to fitnah or disobedience to her father and angering him.
The presenter:
She remains with him, may Allah reward you with good.
Is it obligatory for a girl who lives under the care of her parents, who has reached the age of maturity, or is over twenty-four years old, to visit the sick, such as a neighbor or one of the family members? And is it obligatory for her to maintain family ties? Knowing that her father dislikes her leaving the house out of fear for her from harms, and knowing that her leaving would be with her mother’s permission, and her father is absent from the house, does she sin if she does not perform those visits out of fear of her father’s anger? We ask for your information and guidance, may Allah reward you with good.
Answer:
Visiting relatives, neighbors, and Muslim brothers is undoubtedly a good thing and is encouraged. However, regarding a young woman who is feared to fall into fitnah (trial, discord or temptation) and it is not her custom to go out in public, she does not leave the house. This is called khufrah (seclusion); she is called non-public because fitnah is feared from her. Because her visiting her relatives or her neighbors is a recommended practice (mustahabb), whereas her going out with fitnah is forbidden (haram). So she does not commit a forbidden act in order to perform a recommended practice; because the harm here outweighs the benefit.
The result is that in this matter, benefits, harms, and utilities are considered. So if her going out does not lead to fitnah, then she goes out and visits her relatives and visits her neighbors. But if her going out leads to fitnah or disobedience to her father and angering him.
The presenter:
She remains with him, may Allah reward you with good.
Source
قناة «العلامة الدكتور صالح الفوزان»، هل على الفتاة إثم إذا لم تخرج لزياة أقاربها وصلة رحمها إذا كان والدها يكره خروجها من المنزل وتخشى..؟ — youtube.com
