A man said to his wife: “I swear an oath that you will not go to so-and-so’s house,” but she went. Is this oath considered an oath of divorce?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
The questioner says: If a man says to his wife, for example, “I swear an oath that you will not go to so-and-so’s house,” but she goes, is this oath considered an oath of divorce, or an oath of retraction? And what is its expiation? May Allah reward you with good.
Answer:
His saying “I swear an oath” does not constitute an oath unless he intends divorce by it; in that case, it is one of the indirect expressions. It is one of the indirect expressions; if he intends divorce by it, it is a divorce. As for an oath by Allah, it is not valid except with one of the three letters: waw, ba, or ta. As for his saying “I have sworn” or “I have sworn an oath” or “I have sworn upon you,” none of these constitute a valid oath. Yes.
The questioner says: If a man says to his wife, for example, “I swear an oath that you will not go to so-and-so’s house,” but she goes, is this oath considered an oath of divorce, or an oath of retraction? And what is its expiation? May Allah reward you with good.
Answer:
His saying “I swear an oath” does not constitute an oath unless he intends divorce by it; in that case, it is one of the indirect expressions. It is one of the indirect expressions; if he intends divorce by it, it is a divorce. As for an oath by Allah, it is not valid except with one of the three letters: waw, ba, or ta. As for his saying “I have sworn” or “I have sworn an oath” or “I have sworn upon you,” none of these constitute a valid oath. Yes.
Source
قناة «العلامة الدكتور صالح الفوزان»، قال شخص لزوجته: علي اليمين لا تذهبي إلى بيت فلانة، ولكنها ذهبت، هل هذا الحلف يعتبر يمين طلاق؟ — youtube.com
