A man recited while prostrating: Is the prostration for forgetfulness obligatory upon him?

The questioner : What do you say, Khalid? About a man who recited while prostrating. Yes, intentionally. Praise be to Allah. The professor’s departure is forbidden. In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful. Good. Fine. Others, yes.

The Shaykh : This is the view of those who hold that the prayer is invalidated by recitation during prostration and bowing, and he did so intentionally. Do not be afraid. But on the condition that he performs the obligatory remembrance, on the condition that he performs the obligatory remembrance, “Glory be to my Lord, the Most High” or “Glory be to my Lord, the Most Exalted.” Fine. Those who say that the prayer is not invalidated in this case, brother. Yes, is this your first time attending? Fine. For the sake of.

The questioner : There is no power nor strength except by Allah. The question is, according to those who say that the prayer is not invalidated if one recites during bowing or prostration, how do they answer the well-known principle among the scholars that whoever commits a forbidden act in worship invalidates his prayer? It is prescribed. But it is at the utmost

The Shaykh : In essence, it is prescribed, and the prohibition is in the place, not for the sake of the recitation itself, but because it is in a place other than its proper place. This is contrary to the majority, who hold that the prayer is not broken even if one recites during bowing and prostration. They reasoned that this prohibition is not for the recitation itself, unlike if a person speaks during the prayer, which breaks the prayer, because speech itself is forbidden in the prayer. Fine.