Is it forbidden for a non-resident to enter the state of ihram for Hajj from Makkah?

The questioner : The one who is in Makkah, if he wants to perform Hajj, enters the state of ihram from Makkah, due to the generality of the report of Ibn 'Umar and the action of the Companions. And the one who wants to enter the state of ihram for 'Umrah from Makkah, if we adopt the report of Ibn 'Umar, enters the state of ihram from his location, and the non-resident is specified by the action of 'Aishah.

The Shaykh : Yes.

The questioner : And how do we apply the non-resident in the action of 'Aishah to the non-resident in Hajj, when the generality of "whoever wants" for example in Hajj was not specified?

The Shaykh : No, no, we did not shorten it. We mentioned that for Hajj, the non-resident enters the state of ihram from Makkah. If the non-resident did not have the option to enter the state of ihram from Makkah, it would be obligatory for him to go out to al-Hudaybiyyah.

The questioner : But the one who wants to enter the state of ihram for 'Umrah from Makkah, and he is a resident of Makkah, we said he must go out to al-Hudaybiyyah.

The Shaykh : Yes, because Makkah is not a miqat for 'Umrah.

The questioner : And how do we respond to the claim of specifying a particular area for the furniture?

The Shaykh : This is an error. We have explained its error in terms of evidence and reasoning, but perhaps you have been overcome by drowsiness.