Is it true that some people have criticized the book *Al-Sunnah* by 'Abd Allah ibn Imam Ahmad and the book *Al-Ibanah* by Ibn Batta?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
The questioner says: Some people criticize the book *Al-Sunnah* by 'Abd Allah ibn Imam Ahmad and the book *Al-Ibanah* by Ibn Batta, and they say that these books cause people to be branded as innovators. Is this true? May Allah preserve you.
Answer:
These are excellent books that clarify what has occurred among some people, simplifying matters and pointing toward the good. 'Abd Allah ibn Ahmad wrote, and the author of *Al-Ibanah* and other works wrote. May Allah reward them with good. They clarified many religious innovations (bid'ah) and identified people who warn against the evil of these innovations and the evil of their practitioners. We have read all of it. We read the book of 'Abd Allah ibn Ahmad, which contains much good and a refutation of the religious innovations (bid'ah) that have occurred among some people. Yes.
The questioner says: Some people criticize the book *Al-Sunnah* by 'Abd Allah ibn Imam Ahmad and the book *Al-Ibanah* by Ibn Batta, and they say that these books cause people to be branded as innovators. Is this true? May Allah preserve you.
Answer:
These are excellent books that clarify what has occurred among some people, simplifying matters and pointing toward the good. 'Abd Allah ibn Ahmad wrote, and the author of *Al-Ibanah* and other works wrote. May Allah reward them with good. They clarified many religious innovations (bid'ah) and identified people who warn against the evil of these innovations and the evil of their practitioners. We have read all of it. We read the book of 'Abd Allah ibn Ahmad, which contains much good and a refutation of the religious innovations (bid'ah) that have occurred among some people. Yes.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ ابن باز Alsheikh Binbaz»، 103 هل صحيح طعن بعض الناس في كتاب السنة لعبد الله ابن الإمام أحمد وكتاب الإبانة لابن بطة؟ — youtube.com
The Arabic text is a machine transcription of the audio recording.
