What is the ruling on one who left off stoning the pillars in the past Hajj?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : Shaykh, I went out for Hajj last year, right? Last year I went out for Hajj. At the Jamarat al-Aqabah, I stoned, meaning the first one when we returned from 'Arafah, meaning in the morning, we stoned, yes. The second one the next day, there was a crowd so I did not stone it, and the third day I stoned it.
The Shaykh : I did not stone it at all. Yes, meaning I did not stone the second pillars, and now this year I want to go out for Hajj. What is the ruling on this, my lord? In the past year. Yes, in the past year. I say you must offer a fidyah (ransom payment) that you slaughter in Makkah and distribute to the poor, since you left off the stoning, yes, the second stoning, meaning. You did not stone the second one. Yes, I say you must offer a fidyah. The fidyah is obligatory; if you perform Hajj this year, it does not make up for it. No, no, it does not help. It does not help. You must offer a fidyah that you slaughter in Makkah and distribute to the poor, and your Hajj last year is completed. And what is the ruling on the Hajj this year, which they have opened today? This year it will be a nafilah (voluntary prayer). Meaning it does not become new, right? No, no, no, the first one is gone, but there is only this deficiency and it remains.
The Shaykh : I did not stone it at all. Yes, meaning I did not stone the second pillars, and now this year I want to go out for Hajj. What is the ruling on this, my lord? In the past year. Yes, in the past year. I say you must offer a fidyah (ransom payment) that you slaughter in Makkah and distribute to the poor, since you left off the stoning, yes, the second stoning, meaning. You did not stone the second one. Yes, I say you must offer a fidyah. The fidyah is obligatory; if you perform Hajj this year, it does not make up for it. No, no, it does not help. It does not help. You must offer a fidyah that you slaughter in Makkah and distribute to the poor, and your Hajj last year is completed. And what is the ruling on the Hajj this year, which they have opened today? This year it will be a nafilah (voluntary prayer). Meaning it does not become new, right? No, no, no, the first one is gone, but there is only this deficiency and it remains.
Source
سؤال من حاج 1407هـ - 3 — binothaimeen.net (4:50)
The Arabic text is a machine transcription of the audio recording.
