The Military Pilgrimage Without Permission from His Command
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
If one becomes a member of the military community, he has no right to any leave except what he takes from his own time. Even if he intends to gain reward, he cannot expect his brother to know about it or demand it from him. No one comes from those responsible for him, and also in the case of the eloquent [command], you should avoid [violating] the eloquent [command].
Answer:
Yes, he does not perform Hajj except with permission from his command, because emergencies may occur. Emergencies may occur and they may need him at any hour. Or if he is on leave, if he is on leave, if an emergency occurs or something happens, they summon him. He is on service at any moment. May Allah preserve him, he does not perform Hajj unless he has no connection to the military or they have given him permission. If they had asked for permission, they would have given it to him. They do not go and leave him while they have given him permission. So he is between two things: either they give him permission, or he is under their command at any moment. So he does not enter the state of ihram without knowing, perhaps an order comes to him while he is in ihram or he has not finished. There is no choice in military orders.
If one becomes a member of the military community, he has no right to any leave except what he takes from his own time. Even if he intends to gain reward, he cannot expect his brother to know about it or demand it from him. No one comes from those responsible for him, and also in the case of the eloquent [command], you should avoid [violating] the eloquent [command].
Answer:
Yes, he does not perform Hajj except with permission from his command, because emergencies may occur. Emergencies may occur and they may need him at any hour. Or if he is on leave, if he is on leave, if an emergency occurs or something happens, they summon him. He is on service at any moment. May Allah preserve him, he does not perform Hajj unless he has no connection to the military or they have given him permission. If they had asked for permission, they would have given it to him. They do not go and leave him while they have given him permission. So he is between two things: either they give him permission, or he is under their command at any moment. So he does not enter the state of ihram without knowing, perhaps an order comes to him while he is in ihram or he has not finished. There is no choice in military orders.
Source
قناة «العلامة الدكتور صالح الفوزان»، 13/6 شرح الأصول الثلاثة / صالح الفوزان — youtube.com (1:18:31)
The Arabic text is a machine transcription of the audio recording.
