A person who contracted with a furniture maker and gave him an advance of the amount: what is the operative cause for prohibiting this form of sale?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
May Allah reward you, Honorable Shaykh. This questioner says: A person contracted with a furniture maker to make furniture for him and gave him an advance of the agreed amount. What is the operative cause for prohibiting this form of sale, given that most people engage in this practice?
Answer:
If the contract is a binding contract, it is not permissible until the full price is received in the session of the contract, so that it does not become a sale of a debt for a debt. However, if this is in the nature of a promise—that I will make you chairs or tools, and you will buy them from me when they are ready, or you leave it to your choice to leave them or buy them—then there is nothing wrong with it, because it is not a sale; it is a negotiation and a mutual promise. If it is good, you take it; if it is not good, someone else takes it. This is permissible. But if it is a binding contract, it is not permissible unless you pay the value in the session of the contract, because it becomes like the debt of a forward sale. Yes.
May Allah reward you, Honorable Shaykh. This questioner says: A person contracted with a furniture maker to make furniture for him and gave him an advance of the agreed amount. What is the operative cause for prohibiting this form of sale, given that most people engage in this practice?
Answer:
If the contract is a binding contract, it is not permissible until the full price is received in the session of the contract, so that it does not become a sale of a debt for a debt. However, if this is in the nature of a promise—that I will make you chairs or tools, and you will buy them from me when they are ready, or you leave it to your choice to leave them or buy them—then there is nothing wrong with it, because it is not a sale; it is a negotiation and a mutual promise. If it is good, you take it; if it is not good, someone else takes it. This is permissible. But if it is a binding contract, it is not permissible unless you pay the value in the session of the contract, because it becomes like the debt of a forward sale. Yes.
Source
قناة «العلامة الدكتور صالح الفوزان»، [22 -954] من تعاقد مع صاحب أثاث، وأعطاهم مقدما من المبلغ، ما العلة في منع هذه الصورة من البيع؟ — youtube.com
