What is the ruling on a person performing 'Umrah who comes from France, then stays in Madinah for a week, and then enters the state of ihram for 'Umrah from Abi 'Ara?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
I came from France to perform 'Umrah, intending to stay in Makkah for a week and in Madinah for a week. When the miqat was approaching on the plane, and while I was talking with the flight crew, they told me that it would be easy for me to go to Madinah first, stay there as long as I wished, and then return to Makkah and enter the state of ihram from Abi 'Ara. This is what happened. I arrived in Jeddah, then went to Madinah and stayed there. I then went out to Abi 'Ara and entered the state of ihram. I performed the 'Umrah, but I did not shave my head completely; instead, I cut a little hair from the front, back, and sides of my head. Is this 'Umrah valid? And am I required to perform another 'Umrah during...
Answer:
The 'Umrah is valid. If you came to Jeddah and did not intend to descend to Makkah, but intended to go to Madinah, there is no harm. You go to Madinah, and when you return from Madinah, you enter the state of ihram from the miqat of the people of Madinah and perform the 'Umrah. However, taking some hair from your head like this is not sufficient. It is necessary to take hair from the entire head, as was mentioned in the previous answer. Taking some and leaving some is not sufficient; it must be done comprehensively. Yes.
I came from France to perform 'Umrah, intending to stay in Makkah for a week and in Madinah for a week. When the miqat was approaching on the plane, and while I was talking with the flight crew, they told me that it would be easy for me to go to Madinah first, stay there as long as I wished, and then return to Makkah and enter the state of ihram from Abi 'Ara. This is what happened. I arrived in Jeddah, then went to Madinah and stayed there. I then went out to Abi 'Ara and entered the state of ihram. I performed the 'Umrah, but I did not shave my head completely; instead, I cut a little hair from the front, back, and sides of my head. Is this 'Umrah valid? And am I required to perform another 'Umrah during...
Answer:
The 'Umrah is valid. If you came to Jeddah and did not intend to descend to Makkah, but intended to go to Madinah, there is no harm. You go to Madinah, and when you return from Madinah, you enter the state of ihram from the miqat of the people of Madinah and perform the 'Umrah. However, taking some hair from your head like this is not sufficient. It is necessary to take hair from the entire head, as was mentioned in the previous answer. Taking some and leaving some is not sufficient; it must be done comprehensively. Yes.
Source
قناة «العلامة الدكتور صالح الفوزان»، ما حكم المعتمر القادم من فرنسا ثم مكث في المدينة لمدة أسبوع ثم أحرم بالعمرة من أبيار علي؟ — youtube.com
