She has a dispute with the doctor and the judiciary; should she curse those who wronged her?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
We have Abu Yasser with us from Jeddah. Please, my brother Abu Yasser. Peace be upon you, and Allah's mercy and blessings. Professor 'Abd al-Karim. And upon you be peace and Allah's mercy. My question, O our honorable Shaykh, is as follows. In fact, there was some echo in the voice, so my question is in two parts. The first part, briefly: I have a daughter whom Allah afflicted with an accident, and she became bedridden and paralyzed, completely so. In truth, she was wronged by the doctors, wronged by the judges, and wronged by many others. In fact, there are documents that clarify everything, but my question is as usual. There are those who swear by Allah the Most High when they graduate, whether a doctor, an officer, or a judge, that they will fulfill this oath. So the question is: when you find someone who swore by Allah the Most High, knowing the meaning of this oath, but did not act upon it, and knows that this girl was wronged by him, as a doctor, and also as a judge. The second part of the question is: is it permissible for me, her mother, her, and her brothers to curse those who wronged her in the last part of the night when we stand for prayer? Or when we go out to perform the Fajr prayer in the Noble Makkah, or to perform 'Umrah? May you be given knowledge and safety, and I ask Allah for forgiveness, health, and safety for us and for you.
Answer:
My brother, you mentioned that she was wronged by the judiciary. If her case was brought before the court, we have no involvement in it. The judge reviews it. If you have an objection to the ruling, you submit your objection, and it will be looked into, if Allah wills. As for you claiming that she was wronged, Allah knows best. You claim that the doctor wronged her, and that so-and-so wronged her; Allah knows best. We do not know about this.
The presenter:
Thank you.
We have Abu Yasser with us from Jeddah. Please, my brother Abu Yasser. Peace be upon you, and Allah's mercy and blessings. Professor 'Abd al-Karim. And upon you be peace and Allah's mercy. My question, O our honorable Shaykh, is as follows. In fact, there was some echo in the voice, so my question is in two parts. The first part, briefly: I have a daughter whom Allah afflicted with an accident, and she became bedridden and paralyzed, completely so. In truth, she was wronged by the doctors, wronged by the judges, and wronged by many others. In fact, there are documents that clarify everything, but my question is as usual. There are those who swear by Allah the Most High when they graduate, whether a doctor, an officer, or a judge, that they will fulfill this oath. So the question is: when you find someone who swore by Allah the Most High, knowing the meaning of this oath, but did not act upon it, and knows that this girl was wronged by him, as a doctor, and also as a judge. The second part of the question is: is it permissible for me, her mother, her, and her brothers to curse those who wronged her in the last part of the night when we stand for prayer? Or when we go out to perform the Fajr prayer in the Noble Makkah, or to perform 'Umrah? May you be given knowledge and safety, and I ask Allah for forgiveness, health, and safety for us and for you.
Answer:
My brother, you mentioned that she was wronged by the judiciary. If her case was brought before the court, we have no involvement in it. The judge reviews it. If you have an objection to the ruling, you submit your objection, and it will be looked into, if Allah wills. As for you claiming that she was wronged, Allah knows best. You claim that the doctor wronged her, and that so-and-so wronged her; Allah knows best. We do not know about this.
The presenter:
Thank you.
Source
قناة «العلامة الدكتور صالح الفوزان»، 1842 - لها خصومة مع الطبيب والقضاء، هل تدعو على من ظلمها؟ - الشيخ صالح الفوزان — youtube.com
The Arabic text is a machine transcription of the audio recording.