Is it a sin to delay stoning the pillars after the sun has set for a valid excuse?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
A fatwa with a number. The questioner says: A man says that he stoned the pillars on the second night of the days of Tashriq at ten in the evening, knowing that he was compelled to do so. Is there a sin on him for that or not? Knowing that he was with two women and one man, and they were all sick?
Answer:
The answer: If one delays stoning the pillars on the eleventh day until night overtakes him, and his delay is for a valid legal excuse, and he stoned the pillars at night, then he owes nothing for that. Likewise, if one delays the stoning on the twelfth day and stones them at night, that suffices him and he owes nothing. However, the more cautious course is to strive to stone during the day in the future. And success is from Allah.
A fatwa with a number. The questioner says: A man says that he stoned the pillars on the second night of the days of Tashriq at ten in the evening, knowing that he was compelled to do so. Is there a sin on him for that or not? Knowing that he was with two women and one man, and they were all sick?
Answer:
The answer: If one delays stoning the pillars on the eleventh day until night overtakes him, and his delay is for a valid legal excuse, and he stoned the pillars at night, then he owes nothing for that. Likewise, if one delays the stoning on the twelfth day and stones them at night, that suffices him and he owes nothing. However, the more cautious course is to strive to stone during the day in the future. And success is from Allah.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ ابن باز Alsheikh Binbaz»، 42 هل يأثم من أخّر رمي الجمار بعد زوال الشمس لعذر؟ للإمام ابن باز — youtube.com
The Arabic text is a machine transcription of the audio recording.