How to respond to those who cite the presence of mixing in the Haram as evidence for the permissibility of free mixing of men and women?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
May Allah reward you, Honorable Shaykh. This questioner says: How do we answer the one who says that free mixing of men and women is permissible in the workplace, where they cite that the noblest of the earth's places, the Haram, has mixing between men and women, and that is in the tawaf and the sa'y?
Answer:
This is a defective argument; because mixing was not intended in the Sacred Mosque, nor in the sa'y, nor in the airport. This is something not intended. The one who intends mixing is sinful. This is not intended. So if mixing occurs without intention, this does not fall under what is forbidden.
The mixing that is prohibited is the intended mixing, where one mixes in offices, in schools, and in markets. This is what is forbidden. As for in the mosque, if possible, in the mosque too, the Sacred Mosque, the women are segregated and they have a special prayer area. But if the tawaf or the sa'y occurs and there is some closeness of the man to the woman, it is not intended. And the man in this place fears Allah (Mighty and Majestic) and keeps his distance from the woman, and he does not intend lust, and he does not intend [anything else]; he is only in worship.
As for the one who comes to the tawaf or comes to the sa'y with the intention of mixing with the women, this is forbidden, and he is sinful. Yes.
May Allah reward you, Honorable Shaykh. This questioner says: How do we answer the one who says that free mixing of men and women is permissible in the workplace, where they cite that the noblest of the earth's places, the Haram, has mixing between men and women, and that is in the tawaf and the sa'y?
Answer:
This is a defective argument; because mixing was not intended in the Sacred Mosque, nor in the sa'y, nor in the airport. This is something not intended. The one who intends mixing is sinful. This is not intended. So if mixing occurs without intention, this does not fall under what is forbidden.
The mixing that is prohibited is the intended mixing, where one mixes in offices, in schools, and in markets. This is what is forbidden. As for in the mosque, if possible, in the mosque too, the Sacred Mosque, the women are segregated and they have a special prayer area. But if the tawaf or the sa'y occurs and there is some closeness of the man to the woman, it is not intended. And the man in this place fears Allah (Mighty and Majestic) and keeps his distance from the woman, and he does not intend lust, and he does not intend [anything else]; he is only in worship.
As for the one who comes to the tawaf or comes to the sa'y with the intention of mixing with the women, this is forbidden, and he is sinful. Yes.
Source
قناة «العلامة الدكتور صالح الفوزان»، كيف الرد على من يستدل على جواز الاختلاط بوجود اختلاط في الحرم؟ لمعالي الشيخ صالح الفوزان — youtube.com
The Arabic text is a machine transcription of the audio recording.
