Inquiries regarding "Al-Saqaf" and "Al-Maliki."
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : It is what we heard, O Shaykh, or read, your response to this Al-Saqaf who is here.
Another questioner : Al-Saqaf is finished; he has fallen now.
The questioner : Praise be to Allah.
Another questioner : Praise be to Allah; meaning, he was exposed, and our brothers in Saudi Arabia responded to him, and they responded to himThe Shaykh : onAl-Halabi : , and many brothers there responded to him, and Dr. Nasser al-'Umar, and now there are books responding to him; he is now completely exposed.
The questioner : Was there a response to, for example, his own contradictions in the hadiths he published in his book?
The Shaykh : Ali Hasan read his "Al-Iqtifa" or the book "Al-Anwar al-Kashifah"; it was only on some of the hadiths, not all of them.
Another questioner : There was a response by Dr. Nasser al-'Umar, about four cassettes, to this wretch.
The questioner : Praise be to Allah.
Another questioner : Al-Saqaf is completely exposed among us, but people outside do not know the truth about this man.
The questioner : In Makkah, O Shaykh, his books have spread in Makkah.
Another questioner : Ah, the presence of the Sufis there, Al-Maliki and his helpers.
The questioner : Yes, is he like him, O Shaykh? Is this man declared a disbeliever, O Shaykh?
The Shaykh : ... regarding declaring a Muslim a disbeliever, except under a condition; and that is that he intends to harm the Muslims; it is not necessary, and Allah knows his intention.
Another questioner : But, O our Shaykh, ... he declares the Shaykh al-Islam a disbeliever specifically, this wretch!
The questioner : He declared Ibn al-Jawzi a disbeliever as well, in his book, with his comments in "Daf' Shubhat al-Tashbih."
Another questioner : He declares the Shaykh al-Islam a disbeliever too, the wretch.
The questioner : And even more cunningly, he declares Mu'awiyah (may Allah be pleased with him) a disbeliever, saying: that he is among the people of the Fire!
Another questioner : In a response ... .
The questioner : In a response to him by the Shaykh, do you have a response, O Shaykh, to "Muhammad Ali al-Maliki"?
The Shaykh : Muhammad Ali, who?
The questioner : Muhammad 'Ali al-Maliki, that Makkah Sufi!
Another questioner : The Algerian responded to himThe Shaykh : Abu Bakr responded to him.
The questioner : He responded to him ... do you know his father, O Shaykh? He was in al-Madinah? What is his situation? Is he like him or how?
The Shaykh : He is like him, a Sufi!
The questioner : Meaning, his son reached what he reached in misguidance! He used to teach in the Haram, they say.
The Shaykh : I met him once, on my first trip to Makkah during the first Hajj, and I attended his house, and I found them reciting the Mawlid, so I was surprised at that time; because Saudi Arabia was not lax in this regard at that time, but they were doing it in secret, and now the measure has overflowed.
The questioner : Allah is the Helper.
Another questioner : ... in all the occasions!
The questioner : Did you not discuss anything with him, O Shaykh?
The Shaykh: No.
Another questioner : ... the Jordanian Chief Justice, I remember ... last week ... on television, regarding the permissibility of teaching songs or music in schools, and he said as well that in the time of the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him), he used to promise his companions ... a paper ... .
The Shaykh: Allah is the Greatest!
The questioner : Of course, the people, O Shaykh, all of them, of course, if this judge says something, it means that is the end, they follow him!
The questioner : ... on television or radio, is he saying this?
The questioner : ... he had no presence ... .
The Shaykh : As far as I remember, in Makkah, but I did not stay in al-Madinah, of course, if your question is regarding my first trip, but if your question is when I was at the university, there was, of course!
The questioner : Was the Sufi present?
The Shaykh : Ah. Do you know the story of our brother "Al-Banna" being beaten by some of these pretenders or forgers?
The questioner : I have no news, I did not hear this.
Another questioner : From the Sufis or a fanatic, O Shaykh, of the madhhab?
The Shaykh : Al-Banna (may Allah reward him with good), whenever he saw one of the civilians or others from the strangers, he would stand like this from a distance ... facing the grave, he would advise him, you know "Al-Banna" is kind, so one of these forgers passed by, and when he heard this, he hit him ... .
Another questioner : Al-Saqaf is finished; he has fallen now.
The questioner : Praise be to Allah.
Another questioner : Praise be to Allah; meaning, he was exposed, and our brothers in Saudi Arabia responded to him, and they responded to himThe Shaykh : onAl-Halabi : , and many brothers there responded to him, and Dr. Nasser al-'Umar, and now there are books responding to him; he is now completely exposed.
The questioner : Was there a response to, for example, his own contradictions in the hadiths he published in his book?
The Shaykh : Ali Hasan read his "Al-Iqtifa" or the book "Al-Anwar al-Kashifah"; it was only on some of the hadiths, not all of them.
Another questioner : There was a response by Dr. Nasser al-'Umar, about four cassettes, to this wretch.
The questioner : Praise be to Allah.
Another questioner : Al-Saqaf is completely exposed among us, but people outside do not know the truth about this man.
The questioner : In Makkah, O Shaykh, his books have spread in Makkah.
Another questioner : Ah, the presence of the Sufis there, Al-Maliki and his helpers.
The questioner : Yes, is he like him, O Shaykh? Is this man declared a disbeliever, O Shaykh?
The Shaykh : ... regarding declaring a Muslim a disbeliever, except under a condition; and that is that he intends to harm the Muslims; it is not necessary, and Allah knows his intention.
Another questioner : But, O our Shaykh, ... he declares the Shaykh al-Islam a disbeliever specifically, this wretch!
The questioner : He declared Ibn al-Jawzi a disbeliever as well, in his book, with his comments in "Daf' Shubhat al-Tashbih."
Another questioner : He declares the Shaykh al-Islam a disbeliever too, the wretch.
The questioner : And even more cunningly, he declares Mu'awiyah (may Allah be pleased with him) a disbeliever, saying: that he is among the people of the Fire!
Another questioner : In a response ... .
The questioner : In a response to him by the Shaykh, do you have a response, O Shaykh, to "Muhammad Ali al-Maliki"?
The Shaykh : Muhammad Ali, who?
The questioner : Muhammad 'Ali al-Maliki, that Makkah Sufi!
Another questioner : The Algerian responded to himThe Shaykh : Abu Bakr responded to him.
The questioner : He responded to him ... do you know his father, O Shaykh? He was in al-Madinah? What is his situation? Is he like him or how?
The Shaykh : He is like him, a Sufi!
The questioner : Meaning, his son reached what he reached in misguidance! He used to teach in the Haram, they say.
The Shaykh : I met him once, on my first trip to Makkah during the first Hajj, and I attended his house, and I found them reciting the Mawlid, so I was surprised at that time; because Saudi Arabia was not lax in this regard at that time, but they were doing it in secret, and now the measure has overflowed.
The questioner : Allah is the Helper.
Another questioner : ... in all the occasions!
The questioner : Did you not discuss anything with him, O Shaykh?
The Shaykh: No.
Another questioner : ... the Jordanian Chief Justice, I remember ... last week ... on television, regarding the permissibility of teaching songs or music in schools, and he said as well that in the time of the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him), he used to promise his companions ... a paper ... .
The Shaykh: Allah is the Greatest!
The questioner : Of course, the people, O Shaykh, all of them, of course, if this judge says something, it means that is the end, they follow him!
The questioner : ... on television or radio, is he saying this?
The questioner : ... he had no presence ... .
The Shaykh : As far as I remember, in Makkah, but I did not stay in al-Madinah, of course, if your question is regarding my first trip, but if your question is when I was at the university, there was, of course!
The questioner : Was the Sufi present?
The Shaykh : Ah. Do you know the story of our brother "Al-Banna" being beaten by some of these pretenders or forgers?
The questioner : I have no news, I did not hear this.
Another questioner : From the Sufis or a fanatic, O Shaykh, of the madhhab?
The Shaykh : Al-Banna (may Allah reward him with good), whenever he saw one of the civilians or others from the strangers, he would stand like this from a distance ... facing the grave, he would advise him, you know "Al-Banna" is kind, so one of these forgers passed by, and when he heard this, he hit him ... .
Source
www.al-albany.com
The Arabic text is copied verbatim from the original source, without any edits.