Ibn al-Jawzi mentioned in his *Mawdu'at* a story whose summary is that a woman stood up from the Prophet's (peace and blessings be upon him) gathering, and one of the Companions sat in her place, so he said to him:
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The Shaykh : The questioner is asking a new question here. Ibn al-Jawzi mentioned in his *Mawdu'at* a story whose summary is that a woman stood up from the Prophet's (peace and blessings be upon him) gathering, and one of the Companions sat in her place, so the Messenger of Allah said to him: Some hadith scholars authenticated it by vouching for the reliability of one of the narrators who was criticized, and they refuted Ibn al-Jawzi on this point based on the opinion of some of the Shaykhs. What is your opinion?
The answer in my mind is that the hadith is weak or even weaker, but unfortunately, I do not recall the specific defect of this hadith right now. If the questioner mentions the name of the narrator for whom some hadith scholars claimed reliability, we may be able to confirm for him the weakness of the one mentioned.
Do not sit until her place cools down
لا تجلس حتى يبرد مكانهاThe answer in my mind is that the hadith is weak or even weaker, but unfortunately, I do not recall the specific defect of this hadith right now. If the questioner mentions the name of the narrator for whom some hadith scholars claimed reliability, we may be able to confirm for him the weakness of the one mentioned.
