(The Doubt of Their Denial of Allah and His Attributes) This is the tawhid (the oneness of Allah) according to their group *** like Ibn Sina and al-Nasir al-Thani, they said, and we were compelled to this out of fear
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The Shaykh : The author (may Allah have mercy on him) says:
"This is the tawhid (the oneness of Allah) according to their group *** like Ibn Sina and al-Nasir al-Thani"
Ibn Sina is a well-known man in medicine, and for this reason Arab nationalists glorify him and consider him the scientist, and they commemorate him by naming some institutions after him. As you can see, he is among the most disbelieving of Allah's servants, may Allah protect us from that. And al-Nasir al-Thani, who is called Nasir al-Din al-Tusi, is in reality one who disgraces the religion, not a supporter of the religion.
"They said, and we were compelled to this out of fear of the *** composition and corporeal nature which is false"
These are all doubts; they resorted to saying that this supposed deity, which is conceived in the mind but does not exist in reality, is that they fear composition and corporeal nature.
"And for that reason we said he has no hearing nor *** sight nor knowledge, so how could he have hands"
So they denied the descriptive attributes and said: "so how could he have hands"
Meaning the descriptive attributes, so they denied all the attributes of Allah (Mighty and Majestic). In fact, the truth of the matter is that they denied His existence, because what they mention as Allah is only present in
The student: the minds
The Shaykh : in the mind only
"This is the tawhid (the oneness of Allah) according to their group *** like Ibn Sina and al-Nasir al-Thani"
Ibn Sina is a well-known man in medicine, and for this reason Arab nationalists glorify him and consider him the scientist, and they commemorate him by naming some institutions after him. As you can see, he is among the most disbelieving of Allah's servants, may Allah protect us from that. And al-Nasir al-Thani, who is called Nasir al-Din al-Tusi, is in reality one who disgraces the religion, not a supporter of the religion.
"They said, and we were compelled to this out of fear of the *** composition and corporeal nature which is false"
These are all doubts; they resorted to saying that this supposed deity, which is conceived in the mind but does not exist in reality, is that they fear composition and corporeal nature.
"And for that reason we said he has no hearing nor *** sight nor knowledge, so how could he have hands"
So they denied the descriptive attributes and said: "so how could he have hands"
Meaning the descriptive attributes, so they denied all the attributes of Allah (Mighty and Majestic). In fact, the truth of the matter is that they denied His existence, because what they mention as Allah is only present in
The student: the minds
The Shaykh : in the mind only