So those are excused if they do not wrong *** and disbelieve out of ignorance and aggression (The ruling on this group is that they are excused)
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The Shaykh :"So those are excused if they do not wrong *** and disbelieve out of ignorance and aggression"
The student: ...
The Shaykh : Huh?
The student : If, if.
The Shaykh : I do not have "if" (idh); the corrected version for me is: "if they did not wrong" (idh lam yadhlimu). Do you have the second copy? Are they all "if" (in)? Huh?
The student : Yes.
The Shaykh : The old one?
The student : Which one ...
The Shaykh : Huh? "If" (idh) in one copy, yes, okay, so there are two copies. The one who has "if" (in) should write "if" (idh) in the copy, put a khah in the margin: "if" (in).
What is the difference between "if" (idh) and "if" (in)? "If" (idh) makes the clause explanatory, meaning: so these people are excused because they did not wrong and disbelieve out of ignorance and aggression. As for the copy with "if" (in), it makes the clause conditional, meaning: these people are excused on the condition that they do not wrong and disbelieve out of ignorance and aggression. The outcome of the two copies is the same, meaning whether you make it a condition or an explanation.
The student: ...
The Shaykh : Huh?
The student : If, if.
The Shaykh : I do not have "if" (idh); the corrected version for me is: "if they did not wrong" (idh lam yadhlimu). Do you have the second copy? Are they all "if" (in)? Huh?
The student : Yes.
The Shaykh : The old one?
The student : Which one ...
The Shaykh : Huh? "If" (idh) in one copy, yes, okay, so there are two copies. The one who has "if" (in) should write "if" (idh) in the copy, put a khah in the margin: "if" (in).
What is the difference between "if" (idh) and "if" (in)? "If" (idh) makes the clause explanatory, meaning: so these people are excused because they did not wrong and disbelieve out of ignorance and aggression. As for the copy with "if" (in), it makes the clause conditional, meaning: these people are excused on the condition that they do not wrong and disbelieve out of ignorance and aggression. The outcome of the two copies is the same, meaning whether you make it a condition or an explanation.