Is it permissible to allocate part of his 'Id sacrifice in his home country and part in his place of residence?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : May Allah reward you...
The Shaykh : If it is possible to combine both matters, that is better. For example, if they are a group in a foreign country, that is fine; they sacrifice here and sacrifice there. Yes, but how do these companions sacrifice? Does each person buy a share of the value? Or do we say that each person slaughters, for example, one person this year and another person the next year on behalf of everyone? That is what is intended. Yes, Salim.
The questioner : ...
The Shaykh : They do not pray.
The questioner : They are not Muslims; most of them...
The Shaykh : No, they cannot enter Makkah unless they are Muslims. Do they not pray inside the Haram in the open area? Mina is part of the Haram. No, that is not correct. But in any case, it is better for a person to handle it himself.
Therefore, a person... something strange happens if he gathers a hundred heads and says, "This is for a hundred people," and then they start slaughtering, saying, "This is for so-and-so" and "This is for so-and-so," without specifying. This is a problem, because the charity of each sacrifice is not for him; all of this is not for him. In any case, the most important thing is that he does not think about the outside. These are matters that resemble rituals.
The Shaykh : If it is possible to combine both matters, that is better. For example, if they are a group in a foreign country, that is fine; they sacrifice here and sacrifice there. Yes, but how do these companions sacrifice? Does each person buy a share of the value? Or do we say that each person slaughters, for example, one person this year and another person the next year on behalf of everyone? That is what is intended. Yes, Salim.
The questioner : ...
The Shaykh : They do not pray.
The questioner : They are not Muslims; most of them...
The Shaykh : No, they cannot enter Makkah unless they are Muslims. Do they not pray inside the Haram in the open area? Mina is part of the Haram. No, that is not correct. But in any case, it is better for a person to handle it himself.
Therefore, a person... something strange happens if he gathers a hundred heads and says, "This is for a hundred people," and then they start slaughtering, saying, "This is for so-and-so" and "This is for so-and-so," without specifying. This is a problem, because the charity of each sacrifice is not for him; all of this is not for him. In any case, the most important thing is that he does not think about the outside. These are matters that resemble rituals.