Is it fitting for young people to declare one another innovators over a recommended practice?

The questioner : By the way, there is a necessary question here.

The Shaykh: Yes.

The questioner : Suppose it is a recommended practice; is it a matter of disagreement and discussion, with people saying this and that, and differences and declaring innovation among the young people?

The Shaykh : This is, as we have always said.

The questioner : Suppose it is a recommended practice.

The Shaykh : "The deceased does not deserve this condolence," as we say in the Levant. And in the words of some of the callers: "Say your word and walk away." My brother, distinguish between this being a customary practice, in which case you have no concern for the people, meaning whether they follow you or oppose you; and it being an act of worship, in which case you have no concern after that whether the people oppose you or follow you.

The questioner : Some people say in this context the rule: "Clarification is obligatory and disagreement is forbidden."

The Shaykh : Disagreement is not forbidden.

The questioner : No, not in this context.

The Shaykh : Yes, if Allah wills, oh Allah.