A question about the language of the Hijazis regarding the negative "ma"
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : The established rule
The Shaykh : What?
The questioner : The established rule is the rule of facilitation, O Shaykh, but it has been invalidated here
The Shaykh : Why?
The questioner : Because we preferred, O Shaykh, the opinion of the Hijazis
The Shaykh : And He
The questioner : Which is to employ "ma"
The Shaykh : No, no, may Allah reward you, the language of those who use "ma" is contrary to the scholars; this is a language
The questioner : that is contrary
The Shaykh : No, no, the language
The questioner : that is contrary
The Shaykh : Which one? "Ma Zaydun qayyaman" or "Ma Zaydun qayyum"? This is a disagreement among the grammarians; it is a difference in the language of the Arabs. Which tribe are you from? From Tamim? Most of the people of Najd are from Tamim. So, according to your language, you must say "Ma Zaydun qayyum," correct?
The questioner : Qayyum
The Shaykh : "Ma Zaydun qayyum." And if you said "Ma Zaydun qayyaman" while you are from Tamim, you would be sinful
The questioner : in their view
The Shaykh : in their view, or making a grammatical error; making a grammatical error
The Shaykh : What?
The questioner : The established rule is the rule of facilitation, O Shaykh, but it has been invalidated here
The Shaykh : Why?
The questioner : Because we preferred, O Shaykh, the opinion of the Hijazis
The Shaykh : And He
The questioner : Which is to employ "ma"
The Shaykh : No, no, may Allah reward you, the language of those who use "ma" is contrary to the scholars; this is a language
The questioner : that is contrary
The Shaykh : No, no, the language
The questioner : that is contrary
The Shaykh : Which one? "Ma Zaydun qayyaman" or "Ma Zaydun qayyum"? This is a disagreement among the grammarians; it is a difference in the language of the Arabs. Which tribe are you from? From Tamim? Most of the people of Najd are from Tamim. So, according to your language, you must say "Ma Zaydun qayyum," correct?
The questioner : Qayyum
The Shaykh : "Ma Zaydun qayyum." And if you said "Ma Zaydun qayyaman" while you are from Tamim, you would be sinful
The questioner : in their view
The Shaykh : in their view, or making a grammatical error; making a grammatical error