Is there a disagreement regarding the acceptance of al-Bukhari and Muslim?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
Some students of knowledge subject the chains of narration of al-Bukhari and Muslim to study and critique, saying for example, when al-Bukhari cites a chain: "This is a good hadith," and similarly for Muslim?
Answer:
... The scholars agreed on accepting the two authentic collections, except for a few matters that al-Daraqutni critiqued in Muslim. Otherwise, the scholars agreed on accepting the narrations of the two authentic collections, and by the praise of Allah, after study and attention, their soundness regarding their chains of narration has become clear. The two compilers, al-Bukhari and Muslim, exerted effort in this and selected them from a number of hadiths, may Allah have mercy on them, and their chains of narration are clear.
Some students of knowledge subject the chains of narration of al-Bukhari and Muslim to study and critique, saying for example, when al-Bukhari cites a chain: "This is a good hadith," and similarly for Muslim?
Answer:
... The scholars agreed on accepting the two authentic collections, except for a few matters that al-Daraqutni critiqued in Muslim. Otherwise, the scholars agreed on accepting the narrations of the two authentic collections, and by the praise of Allah, after study and attention, their soundness regarding their chains of narration has become clear. The two compilers, al-Bukhari and Muslim, exerted effort in this and selected them from a number of hadiths, may Allah have mercy on them, and their chains of narration are clear.
Source
binbaz.org.sa
The Arabic text is copied verbatim from the original source, without any edits.