What is the ruling on remembering Allah with the bare pronoun: He, He?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
The Sufis remember Allah with the bare pronoun: He, He?
Answer:
This is a religious innovation (bid'ah); it is not from the remembrance (dhikr), like saying: Allah, Allah. It is not remembrance.
Remembrance is: Subhan Allah, La ilaha illa Allah, as the texts have come; because acts of worship are based on divine legislation (taqwiyyah), they are not to be invented, but the paths to them through reflection and contemplation are prescribed (mashru').
The Sufis remember Allah with the bare pronoun: He, He?
Answer:
This is a religious innovation (bid'ah); it is not from the remembrance (dhikr), like saying: Allah, Allah. It is not remembrance.
Remembrance is: Subhan Allah, La ilaha illa Allah, as the texts have come; because acts of worship are based on divine legislation (taqwiyyah), they are not to be invented, but the paths to them through reflection and contemplation are prescribed (mashru').
Source
binbaz.org.sa
The Arabic text is copied verbatim from the original source, without any edits.