The ruling on obligating the agent to cover the entire loss, or what people commonly overlook, if he sells for less
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : And is the agent obligated to cover the entire loss, or only what exceeds what people commonly overlook? There are two views, and in every case where we said he does not have the authority to sell or buy.
The Shaykh : In this issue. That is, do we say if he sold for less, do we say he is liable for the entire loss, or only for what exceeds what people commonly overlook? For example, if he was told, "Sell for ten," and he sold for ten, or at the market price. Estimation is necessary, but the market price is ten, and he sold it for nine and a half. Is he liable? No, he is not liable, he is not liable, because this is what people commonly overlook. That is, half of ten means one out of twenty; this is the custom. You find this person selling for ten, and that one for nine and a half, and that one for eleven. This is what people overlook. But if we said he sold it for eight, is he liable for one and a half riyals, or two riyals? This is what was at issue, meaning, is he liable for the entire loss, or only for the loss that exceeds what people commonly overlook?
The presenter : And in every case.
The Shaykh : The stronger view is what the evidence indicates.
The presenter : And in every case where we said he does not have the authority to sell or buy, his ruling in it is the ruling of a stranger, and we have mentioned this, because he is not authorized in it.
The Shaykh : His ruling is the ruling of a stranger, and this refers to the action of an unauthorized person. That is, if we said it is not valid, but the principal approved it. The correct view is that if he approves, there is no harm, and that all unauthorized actions, if the one who has the right approves them, are valid and effective. And this is indicated by the fact that Abu Hurayrah (may Allah be pleased with him) gave permission to the one who took from the food. And the Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him) did not hold him liable. Rather, he gave permission and approved of his action.
The Shaykh : In this issue. That is, do we say if he sold for less, do we say he is liable for the entire loss, or only for what exceeds what people commonly overlook? For example, if he was told, "Sell for ten," and he sold for ten, or at the market price. Estimation is necessary, but the market price is ten, and he sold it for nine and a half. Is he liable? No, he is not liable, he is not liable, because this is what people commonly overlook. That is, half of ten means one out of twenty; this is the custom. You find this person selling for ten, and that one for nine and a half, and that one for eleven. This is what people overlook. But if we said he sold it for eight, is he liable for one and a half riyals, or two riyals? This is what was at issue, meaning, is he liable for the entire loss, or only for the loss that exceeds what people commonly overlook?
The presenter : And in every case.
The Shaykh : The stronger view is what the evidence indicates.
The presenter : And in every case where we said he does not have the authority to sell or buy, his ruling in it is the ruling of a stranger, and we have mentioned this, because he is not authorized in it.
The Shaykh : His ruling is the ruling of a stranger, and this refers to the action of an unauthorized person. That is, if we said it is not valid, but the principal approved it. The correct view is that if he approves, there is no harm, and that all unauthorized actions, if the one who has the right approves them, are valid and effective. And this is indicated by the fact that Abu Hurayrah (may Allah be pleased with him) gave permission to the one who took from the food. And the Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him) did not hold him liable. Rather, he gave permission and approved of his action.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، [4804] حكم إلزام الوكيل جميع النقص أو ما يتغابن الناس به إن باع بأقل -تعليقات على الكافي لابن عثيمين
youtube.com
youtube.com
