The Ruling on Permitting Taqlid in Fatwa
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : If you mention dividing the scholar into a community.
The Shaykh : Yes, no, no, we do not divide based on that.
The questioner : No, it means, does it mean? It means
The Shaykh : the one who seeks a fatwa.
The questioner : Yes, yes, I do not mean. Because.
The Shaykh : Because the muqallid. Ibn 'Abd al-Barr mentioned that it is not agreed upon by the scholars by consensus.
The questioner : Yes, yes, I do not mean now the permissibility for the common people, that they take a dispensation in the fatwa, so he is correct in any case, meaning
The Shaykh : the common person must ask the people of knowledge.
The questioner : Yes, yes, no, for example, the permissibility of those who do not say that wudu is required from eating camel meat, and their not taking a dispensation, whereas we do, are they all correct?
The Shaykh : No, as for the common people who have scholars who do not hold this opinion, this is what is obligatory for them; they cannot do otherwise unless the truth becomes clear to them, in which case they must follow it. And as for us, for example, in a place where they say that wudu is obligatory from it, it is not permissible for them to take a dispensation based on the dispensations of other scholars merely for the sake of desire.
The questioner : I mean the common, the common people.
The Shaykh : I follow the three schools of jurisprudence, and I do not perform wudu from camel meat. We say this is not permissible for you, because you only want to take a dispensation. This
The questioner : But are they all correct? Meaning, if those who took a dispensation and those who did not take a dispensation, are they all correct?
The Shaykh : Who are the scholars, or the scholars?
The questioner : Because they did not take a dispensation, and their common people.
The Shaykh : Yes, yes, our common people are correct, because this is the limit of their ability, which is to follow their scholars. And their common people are also like them, correct in the truth that Allah revealed, but correct in their action and their path. Yes.
The questioner : Well, what supports this opinion is that the predecessors of the scholars, may Allah have mercy on them.
The Shaykh : No, no, if they agreed, it would be more merciful, but mercy in the sense that the mercy of Allah encompasses them, so it is not said to this one who disagrees, "You are sinful," even if the truth is with the one who disagrees with him.
The questioner : Yes, but that is the benefit of the common person. The common person who is there.
The Shaykh : The common people did not benefit; they would benefit if we said you are given a choice. But if we said you are now in a place where its scholars do not know except this opinion.
It means that he is bound by it. Therefore, if he is a Shafi'i and al-Shafi'i holds that touching a woman absolutely invalidates wudu, he cannot take a dispensation based on the opinion of one who does not hold that wudu is invalidated, merely for the sake of desire. This results in manipulation, as if we say, follow, for example, Imam Ahmad in that touching a woman does not invalidate wudu, and follow al-Shafi'i in that camel meat does not invalidate wudu, and touch a woman for desire and eat all the meat, then pray. His prayer is now invalid according to both schools. I follow Imam Ahmad in that touching a woman does not invalidate wudu, and I follow al-Shafi'i in that camel meat does not invalidate wudu. He tells you now, your prayer is invalid according to Imam Ahmad and invalid according to al-Shafi'i. And he says, no, what is it to you? Yes, one is at the end of the left. Yes.
The Shaykh : Yes, no, no, we do not divide based on that.
The questioner : No, it means, does it mean? It means
The Shaykh : the one who seeks a fatwa.
The questioner : Yes, yes, I do not mean. Because.
The Shaykh : Because the muqallid. Ibn 'Abd al-Barr mentioned that it is not agreed upon by the scholars by consensus.
The questioner : Yes, yes, I do not mean now the permissibility for the common people, that they take a dispensation in the fatwa, so he is correct in any case, meaning
The Shaykh : the common person must ask the people of knowledge.
The questioner : Yes, yes, no, for example, the permissibility of those who do not say that wudu is required from eating camel meat, and their not taking a dispensation, whereas we do, are they all correct?
The Shaykh : No, as for the common people who have scholars who do not hold this opinion, this is what is obligatory for them; they cannot do otherwise unless the truth becomes clear to them, in which case they must follow it. And as for us, for example, in a place where they say that wudu is obligatory from it, it is not permissible for them to take a dispensation based on the dispensations of other scholars merely for the sake of desire.
The questioner : I mean the common, the common people.
The Shaykh : I follow the three schools of jurisprudence, and I do not perform wudu from camel meat. We say this is not permissible for you, because you only want to take a dispensation. This
The questioner : But are they all correct? Meaning, if those who took a dispensation and those who did not take a dispensation, are they all correct?
The Shaykh : Who are the scholars, or the scholars?
The questioner : Because they did not take a dispensation, and their common people.
The Shaykh : Yes, yes, our common people are correct, because this is the limit of their ability, which is to follow their scholars. And their common people are also like them, correct in the truth that Allah revealed, but correct in their action and their path. Yes.
The questioner : Well, what supports this opinion is that the predecessors of the scholars, may Allah have mercy on them.
The Shaykh : No, no, if they agreed, it would be more merciful, but mercy in the sense that the mercy of Allah encompasses them, so it is not said to this one who disagrees, "You are sinful," even if the truth is with the one who disagrees with him.
The questioner : Yes, but that is the benefit of the common person. The common person who is there.
The Shaykh : The common people did not benefit; they would benefit if we said you are given a choice. But if we said you are now in a place where its scholars do not know except this opinion.
It means that he is bound by it. Therefore, if he is a Shafi'i and al-Shafi'i holds that touching a woman absolutely invalidates wudu, he cannot take a dispensation based on the opinion of one who does not hold that wudu is invalidated, merely for the sake of desire. This results in manipulation, as if we say, follow, for example, Imam Ahmad in that touching a woman does not invalidate wudu, and follow al-Shafi'i in that camel meat does not invalidate wudu, and touch a woman for desire and eat all the meat, then pray. His prayer is now invalid according to both schools. I follow Imam Ahmad in that touching a woman does not invalidate wudu, and I follow al-Shafi'i in that camel meat does not invalidate wudu. He tells you now, your prayer is invalid according to Imam Ahmad and invalid according to al-Shafi'i. And he says, no, what is it to you? Yes, one is at the end of the left. Yes.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 1259- مناقشات في الإجتهاد والتقليد /كتاب التوحيد📕/ابن عثيمين
youtube.com
youtube.com
