The ruling on publishing a book containing weak hadith in a da'wah gathering
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner: Shaykh, I am not comfortable.
The Shaykh: Yes, if the chair is tilted and I am upright, it is fine.
The questioner: Yes, yes.
The Shaykh: Okay, it is permissible for all of us.
The questioner: It is better to straighten the chair, I will move back a little.
The Shaykh: No, I am not sitting, I am done.
The questioner: Because my legs are not comfortable. Or it cannot be done.
The Shaykh: My dear, the situation is fine, be comfortable.
The questioner: From here?
The Shaykh: Buy it. What is it, Tahir? Yes, it happened recently. A school teacher. Of course, she is Salafi in methodology and excellent, and I do not hold back or sting with her regarding the use of the term "da'iyyah" (female caller) for women, so I do not hold back or sting with her.
The questioner: Please, please, may Allah give you health. Peace be upon you.
The Shaykh: And upon you be peace. Please. Welcome, hello, how are you? I allow myself to say that she is truly a da'iyyah, but not like the da'iyyah who are employed in a position, and she is very enthusiastic about the Salafi da'wah. And also enthusiastic about that man whom you were afflicted with. And.
The questioner: Fawziyah London.
The Shaykh: So she does not take a word without wanting to spread it in any manner or without manner, and this is the point.
The questioner: That, that.
The Shaykh: Or. She believed in a book from the books of summaries. That it is a beneficial book. And especially since the author of this book. Has a connection to the da'wah or to the da'i, say what you want. So she desired to print this book. And spend on it. So she contacted the Islamic office and the land is now inhabited, no, it is fine, no harm. So it was told to her that this book is not approved of. So immediately she contacted the woman to me. The man answered that, by Allah, he had not studied the book in terms of its content until he could give an opinion on it, but he has a viewpoint from another angle, which is that this book contains many weak hadith, and some of them are fabricated, and the man dared and exceeded his limit and sat down to authenticate and weaken as he pleased. So in my belief, I was fair to the man, meaning I did not judge his book as good or bad because I have not studied it, but the aspect that he studied, or I, or he, excuse me, meaning it is the prevalence of printing, meaning he studied the topic, so he gave the definitive ruling that from the hadith perspective, it is zero on the left. The point is she took this statement from the man. And in a gathering with a group of women, some of whom have been in the da'wah for a long time and some are new, and advice, "O my daughters, O my sisters," and she announced it to the gathering, there is a noble woman there, and. She has some wisdom, and perhaps more than necessary, meaning sometimes, so she hinted to her that hold on a little, the land does not reconcile with this, but she proceeded. Finally, a woman came to me and told me the story, and what is your opinion on this matter? I told her, of course, she is wrong, the most wrong, because not everything that is known should be said, and I thought she would contact me so that I could understand the matter, and I am making up in my mind
The questioner: We are looking.
The Shaykh: Huh? I am making up in my mind, I am preparing in my mind, I am forming in my mind, to remind her of a hadith, this hadith. Imam al-Bukhari titled it "We are in most need of it," and it has a relation to the style of da'wah, not every hadith is to be narrated to the common people, not every hadith is to be narrated to the common people. Do not advise one who is eager, the believer does not start with loudness twice.
The questioner: We will answer.
The Shaykh: Ha ha. I am not saying it. I am in a hurry. Blond like the story of the cheese, it is done.
The questioner: Even though they say these whites have coldness, the opposite of what I understand.
The Shaykh: These, my dear, the whites are like the Samr in Mecca and in Mecca.
The questioner: Definitely so. Mentioned the name of the walker.
The Shaykh: Yes, how? Do not mumble. The hadith that al-Bukhari mentioned. It is that the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him). Mu'adh ibn Jabal (may Allah be pleased with him) was riding behind him, so he said to him (peace and blessings be upon him), "O Mu'adh, shall I not give you good news?" He said, "Yes, O Messenger of Allah," he repeated to him, what is the name of the one, he said. There is no Muslim who testifies that there is no god but Allah and that Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah, sincerely from his heart, except that Allah has forbidden his body from the Fire,
The Shaykh: Yes, if the chair is tilted and I am upright, it is fine.
The questioner: Yes, yes.
The Shaykh: Okay, it is permissible for all of us.
The questioner: It is better to straighten the chair, I will move back a little.
The Shaykh: No, I am not sitting, I am done.
The questioner: Because my legs are not comfortable. Or it cannot be done.
The Shaykh: My dear, the situation is fine, be comfortable.
The questioner: From here?
The Shaykh: Buy it. What is it, Tahir? Yes, it happened recently. A school teacher. Of course, she is Salafi in methodology and excellent, and I do not hold back or sting with her regarding the use of the term "da'iyyah" (female caller) for women, so I do not hold back or sting with her.
The questioner: Please, please, may Allah give you health. Peace be upon you.
The Shaykh: And upon you be peace. Please. Welcome, hello, how are you? I allow myself to say that she is truly a da'iyyah, but not like the da'iyyah who are employed in a position, and she is very enthusiastic about the Salafi da'wah. And also enthusiastic about that man whom you were afflicted with. And.
The questioner: Fawziyah London.
The Shaykh: So she does not take a word without wanting to spread it in any manner or without manner, and this is the point.
The questioner: That, that.
The Shaykh: Or. She believed in a book from the books of summaries. That it is a beneficial book. And especially since the author of this book. Has a connection to the da'wah or to the da'i, say what you want. So she desired to print this book. And spend on it. So she contacted the Islamic office and the land is now inhabited, no, it is fine, no harm. So it was told to her that this book is not approved of. So immediately she contacted the woman to me. The man answered that, by Allah, he had not studied the book in terms of its content until he could give an opinion on it, but he has a viewpoint from another angle, which is that this book contains many weak hadith, and some of them are fabricated, and the man dared and exceeded his limit and sat down to authenticate and weaken as he pleased. So in my belief, I was fair to the man, meaning I did not judge his book as good or bad because I have not studied it, but the aspect that he studied, or I, or he, excuse me, meaning it is the prevalence of printing, meaning he studied the topic, so he gave the definitive ruling that from the hadith perspective, it is zero on the left. The point is she took this statement from the man. And in a gathering with a group of women, some of whom have been in the da'wah for a long time and some are new, and advice, "O my daughters, O my sisters," and she announced it to the gathering, there is a noble woman there, and. She has some wisdom, and perhaps more than necessary, meaning sometimes, so she hinted to her that hold on a little, the land does not reconcile with this, but she proceeded. Finally, a woman came to me and told me the story, and what is your opinion on this matter? I told her, of course, she is wrong, the most wrong, because not everything that is known should be said, and I thought she would contact me so that I could understand the matter, and I am making up in my mind
The questioner: We are looking.
The Shaykh: Huh? I am making up in my mind, I am preparing in my mind, I am forming in my mind, to remind her of a hadith, this hadith. Imam al-Bukhari titled it "We are in most need of it," and it has a relation to the style of da'wah, not every hadith is to be narrated to the common people, not every hadith is to be narrated to the common people. Do not advise one who is eager, the believer does not start with loudness twice.
The questioner: We will answer.
The Shaykh: Ha ha. I am not saying it. I am in a hurry. Blond like the story of the cheese, it is done.
The questioner: Even though they say these whites have coldness, the opposite of what I understand.
The Shaykh: These, my dear, the whites are like the Samr in Mecca and in Mecca.
The questioner: Definitely so. Mentioned the name of the walker.
The Shaykh: Yes, how? Do not mumble. The hadith that al-Bukhari mentioned. It is that the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him). Mu'adh ibn Jabal (may Allah be pleased with him) was riding behind him, so he said to him (peace and blessings be upon him), "O Mu'adh, shall I not give you good news?" He said, "Yes, O Messenger of Allah," he repeated to him, what is the name of the one, he said. There is no Muslim who testifies that there is no god but Allah and that Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah, sincerely from his heart, except that Allah has forbidden his body from the Fire,
Source
سلسلة الهدى والنور، المجلس 1230 — d3watuna.com (22:29)
The Arabic text is a machine transcription of the audio recording.