Is the 'Asr prayer made up if its time has passed?

The questioner: ... meaning it is considered ... but ... .

The Shaykh: How did you not understand what I said? I mean, is your case different from Abu Ahmad's case?

The questioner: It is the same case, but a continuation ... the systematic method is not ... .

The Shaykh: It is considered a systematic method.

The questioner: It is considered a systematic method ... .

The Shaykh: I have answered this question, but the disagreement between you and him is not our concern; I do not know whether it is this way or that way, and I do not know.

The questioner : ... .

Another questioner: Personal relationships, I mean.

The Shaykh: But the legal ruling is as follows.

Another questioner: I mean, I.

The questioner: Professor, regarding the prayer, there is a hadith about combining the Dhuhr and 'Asr prayers. Abdullah ibn Abbas said ... but there is ... I prayed Dhuhr, and I do not want to combine.

The Shaykh: I did not intend to combine.

The questioner: I did not intend it. I prayed Dhuhr and the sunnah, and I continued on the basis that I would pray 'Asr, but I was occupied such that I could not pray ... or I was occupied ... and Maghrib had already been called; so how do I pray 'Asr? Is it combined with Maghrib? It is not combined; because its time has passed. So how does the 'Asr prayer come about in this case? Do I make it up as a missed prayer?

The Shaykh: The prayer has passed for you.

The questioner: Huh?

The Shaykh: The prayer has passed.

The questioner: He does not pray it at all.

The Shaykh: If it was without an excuse of sleep or forgetfulness, the prayer has passed; whether he intended to combine and did not intend it; meaning - without blame - the scenario you started with has no relation to the reality of the question; because whether he prayed Dhuhr and wanted to combine 'Asr or did not want to combine; the scenario is simpler than this: a person entered the time of 'Asr and then did not pray until the sun set; so does he make up this prayer or not? The answer is what I said earlier: if this prayer did not pass him due to a legal excuse, and that is nothing but sleep or forgetfulness; then there is no way to make up what he missed of this prayer. But if he forgot it or slept through it, then he prays it when he remembers it.