It is mentioned in the narration of Dhu al-Yadayn a version containing (so they gestured, meaning yes); what is the degree of its authenticity?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : We return to the previous discussion regarding the hadith of Dhu al-Yadayn.
The Shaykh: Yes.
The questioner : The narration of Abu Dawud is found in the authentic Sunan of Abu Dawud. Your narration of Abu Dawud meaning when he asked them so they gestured, meaning yes, you said about it that it is authentic.
The Shaykh: Yes.
The questioner : Then Abu Dawud denied it, and you said it is authentic. Abu 'Amr ibn 'Abd al-Barr said, I am now quoting from al-Tamhid. Abu 'Amr said: Abu Dawud said: "Everyone who narrated this hadith did not say فأومأوا So they gestured except Hammad ibn Zayd." What is your opinion regarding this?
The Shaykh : This requires tracing the chains of narration. If it is true, as is suspected, that Hammad ibn Zayd was unique in narrating it, then it is anomalous.
The Shaykh: Yes.
The questioner : The narration of Abu Dawud is found in the authentic Sunan of Abu Dawud. Your narration of Abu Dawud
So they gestured, meaning yes
فأومأوا أي نعمIs Dhu al-Yadayn truthful?
أصدق ذو اليدينThe Shaykh: Yes.
The questioner : Then Abu Dawud denied it, and you said it is authentic. Abu 'Amr ibn 'Abd al-Barr said, I am now quoting from al-Tamhid. Abu 'Amr said: Abu Dawud said: "Everyone who narrated this hadith did not say فأومأوا So they gestured except Hammad ibn Zayd." What is your opinion regarding this?
The Shaykh : This requires tracing the chains of narration. If it is true, as is suspected, that Hammad ibn Zayd was unique in narrating it, then it is anomalous.
Source
www.al-albany.com
The Arabic text is copied verbatim from the original source, without any edits.